Proposal: Josh Manson to Toronto

[TheGroceryStick]

toronto has had very little problem getting players to waive.

the only player i know of who was rumor to have wanted to block a trade to TO was Brodie


And he signed that summer

Kadri blocked that trade. (Not sure if someone said this already, i dont wanna read)

 

[Legion34]

Kadri blocked that trade. (Not sure if someone said this already, i dont wanna read)

Yes. And Mirtle said Brodie put to on his NTC after.

then he signed so…..

 

[TheGroceryStick]

Yes. And Mirtle said Brodie put to on his NTC after.

then he signed so…..

Oh. Fair. Didn't know that

 

[Legion34]

Oh. Fair. Didn't know that

to be fair. The only person who said it was Mirtle on his podcast. No one else seemed to confirm it

 

[Brixton]

Thought Holl was supposed to be “good” and a great find for the Leafs. Guess it’s time to run him out of town though as is tradition.

Hill was suppose to be great, lilligren was untouchable, gauthier was a steal, Rielly was going to win the Norris, Boston was an easy series win, Chara was too old, leafs have the best center depth….all just a dream now for leaf fans.

 

[Fogelhund]

Thought Holl was supposed to be “good” and a great find for the Leafs. Guess it’s time to run him out of town though as is tradition.

He was good... for like 25-30 games... and then that was it.

 

[The Podium]

Manson is a minimal upgrade on Holl, if at all. So no.

 

[Trojans86]

Remember when Ducks fans were saying Manson is an elite D and will be a #1D and said they wouldn't do Manson for Nylander straight up lol, good times.

I follow the ducks very closely and have never ever heard that. Please find it for me.

 

[AvroArrow]

I follow the ducks very closely and have never ever heard that. Please find it for me.

Already have, some Ducks fans were asking for Matthews for Manson. Maybe it wasn't you, but a lot of them were throwing ridiculous proposals out there for Manson.

 

[Trojans86]

Already have, some Ducks fans were asking for Matthews for Manson. Maybe it wasn't you, but a lot of them were throwing ridiculous proposals out there for Manson.

Shit, you did. In fairness I think all of those were under the premise that he isn’t available unless it is a big overpayment. Also have to realize that he dropped off. For awhile he was very good as a physical top pair d. Not anymore.

 

[Sniperberg]

Not even close!!

On second thought i agree. Toronto might have to add a 1st round pick.

 

[Jerkbait]

Manson is a minimal upgrade on Holl, if at all. So no.

Agreed not enough to start conversations. Now Manson for one of the cookie cutter forwards might be something

 

[CreeksideStrangler]

To : Josh Manson(50% retained)

To2: Justin Holl, 2nd round pick, 4th round pick

Manson? did you get stuck in an HF trade forum timewarp and rewind to 5 years ago?? its 2021.