Yeah. I think the Leafs and the core players are entering that contending window where the bar is really high. Regular season success is only a stepping stone and tune up for the real playoff test ahead - but at the same time, regular season underachieving is not acceptable.
I would compare this level of expectation to the 1996 and 1997 Detroit Red Wings. They won a record 62 games in 1996 and came close to beating Montreal's all time regular season points total with 131, but fell short to the Avalanche who won the cup.
The next year, they fell back to earth at 94 points, which was heavily criticized even though no one cared about their regular season play, but was made up for with their ability to take the next step to become champions.
On the surface these expectations feel unreasonable but it says a lot about the capabilities of the team and where they are headed.