Beer and Chips
Registered User
- Feb 5, 2018
- 1,460
- 1,096
Hope him the best of luck but he'll be dismissed because he is a late round pick, management is consumed with ratings.
Prospect Info: Jared Davidson
- Thread starter Adam Michaels
- Start date
Adam Michaels
Registered User
26Mats
Registered User
- Jun 23, 2018
- 33,045
- 25,469
RHP got his shot. I think RHP will start out on the 4th line. But he'll get another shot in the top 9 at some point.
Beer and Chips
Registered User
- Feb 5, 2018
- 1,460
- 1,096
Both confirmed my post, Hoffman over RHP in the top six because he is the better talent, sure.
Estimated_Prophet
Registered User
- Mar 28, 2003
- 11,015
- 12,111
The whole league preaches respect for the veterans. They’ve been through the entry level contracts, the cheap bridges, their health is gone. Coaches have to cut them some slack or they lose the room.Both confirmed my post, Hoffman over RHP in the top six because he is the better talent, sure.
MXD
Partying Hard
- Oct 27, 2005
- 51,313
- 17,174
If Hoffman has clout in this room, well... Probably better off changing the whole room.
Hat trick today in the intra squad game
Honest question, as I know exactly nothing about this kid. But, is he a sleeper? 5th round pick, but over his W career, his stats appear to be decent. I didn't see todays scrimmage, but is he a Roy level prospect, or should we consider him a Mysak level guy.
Let's GET PUMPED over his Hatty!!!
Let's GET PUMPED over his Hatty!!!
He was signed to an AHL contract so he has work to do to earn an NHL contract. This is the same route Rahael Harvey-Pinard went through. So right now he isn't considered a top prospect.
Not a Roy level prospect. Generally considered as more of a potential 4th line level guy, maybe 3rd line.
He was #20 on the HF habs ranking. Ahead of Simoneau and Mysak, below Kapanen, Tuch and Rohrer.
Redux91
I do Three bullets.
Well, we gotta remember we drafted this kid at 19 and a month later he was 20
So it was a overager 'let's see' pick, but he's definitely showing he can play a little
Ezpz
No mad pls
- Apr 16, 2013
- 15,116
- 11,505
To be fair Roy is a hometown boy and was drafted in his first eligible year. Nobody had heard of Davidson and he was drafted in his final eligible year. He had a follow up D+1(D+3 I guess technically) where he largely didn't improve on the previous year number wise. Roy was a faller who lit up the Q the following year and looked pretty good at camp and the world juniors.
Davidson played in a much stronger league than the Q and was the best or 'go to' player on a team with 14 drafted prospects including Lambert, Korchinski, Colton Dach, Guenther, and Reid Schaeffer. I think bringing in all those big names also took away from his ice time, which would explain the plateau in numbers. He also went to the WHL finals twice in a row as the #1C.
The guy is pretty thick and average NHL height but hasn't shown his standout skills to Habs fans yet because few follow the WHL here. These kinds of players always get slept on in rankings versus guys who played at the world juniors or locally. The overage thing is already docked marks when people rank prospects, then not making the juniors, not leading the league in scoring, etc. Ironically he probably scores more if his team wasn't so deep, then people would probably overhype him.
Now I am not saying I think he's a better prospect than Roy. I am simply saying I wouldn't be shocked to see Davidson be the best rookie forward in Laval, and I wouldn't be shocked to see him fizzle out completely. I never trust HFHabs rankings cause historically they have never been right. Poehling over Suzuki anyone? Yannick Weber over Subban? Bogdan Konyushkov was just ranked 18th and will probably be top 5 next year. Jake Evans ended up passing every single forward prospect we had including Poehling, Audette, Vejdemo, Hudon, McCarron, Scherbak, etc, and became the only forward NHLer from that period after Chucky and Lehkonen.
HF Habs: - Final 2020 HfHabs Prospect Rankings
1. Alexander Romanov (50.0%) (+4) 2. Cole Caufield (85.4%) (-) 3. Mattias Norlinder (43.9%) (+9) 4. Kaiden Guhle (48.1%) (NA) 5. Cayden Primeau (84.6%) (+1) 6. Ryan Poehling (47.8%) (-5) 7. Jordan Harris (28.9%) (+3) 8. Jan Mysak (41.2%) (NA) 9. Josh Brook (27.5% , Tiebreaker 68.5 %) (-5) 10...
Just for fun take a look at three years ago. Norlinder and Romanov over Guhle. Romanov over Caufield. Pezzetta 37th. RHP 25th. Ylonen dropped a ton to all the recent picks (who have mostly busted). I'd also so much of this board, myself included at times, didn't even think Jayden Struble was going to get signed because of his lack of progression in the NCAA and now it seems like he's going to get high priority minutes in Laval.
He should have been ahead of all 5 players mentioned.
WeThreeKings
Demidov is a HAB
If he makes it (barring progression that can happen at any age) he's going to be your 4th line forward. Adds a touch of scoring, adds some sand paper, can probably slide up the line-up for short periods of time to add some of that to a skilled line.
Not a bad gamble.
Not a bad gamble.
Tuch and Rohrer maybe, but disagree on Kapanen.
All of those 3 not being at training camp coupled with Davidson's hat trick (the Poehling effect) is likely influencing a lot of people's opinion on the matter.
Scintillating10
Registered User
Team_Spirit
95% Elliotte
- Jul 3, 2002
- 38,885
- 20,193
Got this nice apple then got kneed and only played 8 minutes. I'd like to see him get another game.
Ezpz
No mad pls
- Apr 16, 2013
- 15,116
- 11,505
I didn't even realize this kid doesn't have an ELC. He is outplaying nearly everyone who does. I'm guessing they'll announce mid-season he's signed starting in 2024-25.
Yep, he went down the RHP route in that RHP was drafted I think at 20 and only earned an AHL contract. RHP of course proved himself and earned an NHL entry level contract less than a year later. I think Simoneau is also on an AHL deal, I could be wrong.
Adam Michaels
Registered User
Yup. He's going the RHP/Simoneau route. AHL deal while we still have your NHL rights for another year. And if you earn it, we'll sign you to an ELC. They're doing the same with Tourigny.
This kid is looking good,better than some of those that were expected ahead of him.
Kudo Shinichi
Registered User
- Apr 20, 2012
- 21,053
- 27,806
It's good that the current management is using the RHP route. Once you hit the late rounds it's very unusual to find good picks. It's worth taking a shot at late bloomers, guys in weak leagues, and other oddities.
I saw some of Davidson's memorial cup games and I wasn't expecting much. He has been really good this preseason.
Draft position doesn't matter after the fact if the player is good. If Davidson plays well enough he will get ahead. Draft position can matter for players who have not done so well. It's rare for late picks to work out and, correspondingly rare for them to bloom late. It's not all that rare for top picks to break out a year or four later than expected. There is value to a 23 year old who was picked high even if he hasn't done well, but not so much for a player with similar stats the same age picked in the fifth round.
