Alf Silfversson
Registered User
- Jun 8, 2011
- 5,768
- 5,490
How does listing three guys with a combined zero games of experience, who would be lucky to even get a cup of coffee in the NHL, prove your point?
Look at the most successful playoff teams of the past few years. I'll point out all the 'tall guys' above 6'3, and comment on their height/weight.
In the 2013 finals, there was Chara, at 6'9, 255, Adam McQuaid at a lean 6'5, 215, and Brent Seabrooke at 6'3, 220. That's it for big/tall guys on defense for either team, and McQuaid is built like Weircioch. This year alone, Ottawa has 5 guys that would qualify for this list.
In the 2012 finals, there wasn't a defenseman out there for either team bigger than Andy Greene, who is Marc Methot's size at 6'3, 230. Willie Mitchell is 6'3, 210. Mark Fayne, and Adam Larsson were the big guys for the Devils, at 6'3, 220. Lots of smaller, mobile defensemen though.
In the 2011 finals, we had Chara and McQuaid again, as well as Andrew Alberts, at 6'5 218, Edler at 6'3, 215, and Sami Salo, at 6'3, 315. So four of the five defensemen between both cup contending teams that registered above 6'3 were relatively lean; weighing below 220 lbs.
2010 had Braydon Coburn at 6'5, 220, and Chris Pronger at 6'6, 220, as well as the aforementioned Brent Seabrook at 6'3, 220. That's it for big and tall.
We aren't seeing tall, heavy set defensemen have as much success at the NHL level anymore. They can't keep up, and are initially scouted because of their size, not their ability to play hockey. It's that inability to play that weeds them out at the highest levels, and the tall defensemen that succeed in today's NHL are lean.
Jared Cowen, by all accounts, is now 6'6, 240+. He's not lean by any stretch; he's a big dude. There were plenty of successful defensemen like him prior to the 2004 lockout, but once teams realized that defensemen needed the ability to accelerate from a standstill, they got weeded out. Jared Cowen cannot accelerate. He gets caught. He has a pre-lockout body type. It almost burned us last night when Dubinsky flew by him and got a point blank chance to tie it late in the game. He's not mobile. That's why I'm afraid.
I agree that most huge defensemen now get weeded out and there are definitely less of the Chris Therien, late Derian Hatcher, Kyle McLaren type of guys in the league now.
Mobility is a must now. Big guys who can't keep up are being either weeded out or beaten. The best example is close to home. The big slow guys on the Sens D is the biggest reason for our defensive struggles. Guys like Phillips, Gryba, Cowen and Wiercioch have been exposed for their lack of footspeed and skill, particularly early in the season. Loading up on big guys who can't skate is a recipe for disaster in today's NHL
That being said Cowen has the ability to be mobile AND big. He also shows some flashes of contributing offense. Marc Methot last year was extremely valuable to the Sens because of his combination of size and speed. I have no doubt that Cowen has that kind of potential and maybe even a higher ceiling.