Moving Dobson to get Hagens so we can still draft Schaefer is ridiculous. It's basically moving Dobson for a player who might be as good as him one day. If Hagens was from Michigan, Canada, Europe, anywhere other than Long Island this wouldn't be a discussion. Taking the blinders off-yes it would be nice to get Hagens-and sure if he was still projected to be the #1 pick-or even in the conversation-it would be a great story if we got him. But it's just not meant to be and that's fine.
The best thing to do is not to overthink it and take Schaefer. If drafting a defensemen who only played in 17 games is seen as too risky that's fine-take Misa. Taking Hagens at #1 no longer makes sense and neither does moving Dobson to get him.
The last time we drafted 1st overall there were some talks about whether we'd take the defensemen or one of the two forwards. If Duchene was from Long Island and we took him over Tavares or Hedman that would go down as a terrible choice.