Toggle sidebar

Jack Michaels - Oilers PBP

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates

Jack Micaels game calling during the play ....

  • ..Is fine the way it is.

    Votes: 90 40.4%

  • ...needs to be more about the actual game and less about background stories.

    Votes: 133 59.6%
  • Total voters
    223
JordanGalhanth said:
It's trickle-down of the culture that has plagued this team for years... The quality of work gets sacrificed on the altar of personal favouritism.
Click to expand...

Solid point.
I would like to think that the team is beyond that now. I least I hope they are.
 
Asher said:
Micheals is terrible, but I doubt that's a controversial opinion. The real blame, imo, belongs on Stauffer though. I still remember when they were looking for a new pbp guy, and Bob talked a little about the process on his radio show. He let it drop that he had a major say in the hiring, and that the having chemistry with him (ie. Bob) was a key requirement for any applicant. Watching them together, it's pretty obvious to me that they cared a lot more about finding someone who could tolerate Bob's personality (and that ain't easy task) than someone who could do the job.
Click to expand...

So.......if they get rid of Stauffer, Michaels will be a goner as well. No wonder Bob is such a suck up shill.
 
Listened to about 2 minutes of the Michaels show last night while I was driving home from work, and had to shut it off in frustration, just couldn't stand it anymore. The play was continuing, but he honestly could not mention the person involved in the play, without offering up some inane fact about them, and on and on it went. Had no idea what was going on, on the ice.
 
Michaels has been auditioning for a TV gig since he got here (almost landed one with the King's last year IIRC). His play by play is awful for radio but well suited to TV.

I can't listen to him on the radio because the actual game seems like an after thought to him and he would rather talk about some players cousin or uncle.
 
Stoneman89 said:
Listened to about 2 minutes of the Michaels show last night while I was driving home from work, and had to shut it off in frustration, just couldn't stand it anymore. The play was continuing, but he honestly could not mention the person involved in the play, without offering up some inane fact about them, and on and on it went. Had no idea what was going on, on the ice.
Click to expand...
It’s Pierre McGuire esque
 
Separate but related note...I somehow missed that former CTV Edmonton sports reporter Bryan Mudryk is now doing play-by-play on TSN. He called the Sens/Kings game and I was thoroughly impressed. He sounds like a cross between Rod and Chris Cuthbert.

If the opportunity ever presents itself, I would love for him to somehow take over for Jack.

Of course, that'll probably happen in the same year that the Oilers win the Stanley Cup... :sarcasm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: guymez
Asher said:
Micheals is terrible, but I doubt that's a controversial opinion. The real blame, imo, belongs on Stauffer though. I still remember when they were looking for a new pbp guy, and Bob talked a little about the process on his radio show. He let it drop that he had a major say in the hiring, and that the having chemistry with him (ie. Bob) was a key requirement for any applicant. Watching them together, it's pretty obvious to me that they cared a lot more about finding someone who could tolerate Bob's personality (and that ain't easy task) than someone who could do the job.
Click to expand...

Jack is probably a big fan of the Mediterranean chicken too.

(I actually like him as pbp though.)
 
Had to bump this thread because of the sheer unprofessionalism that happened on air tonight.

Was listening to the game on my way home, and heard the usual amount of useless trivia instead of calling the game. But then in addition, Jack spent a good 30-40 seconds - during the play, of course - to specifically boast about how he and Bob are the only broadcast duo in the whole league who pronounce Elias Petterson's name the right way. "It's El-EEis, not Elias...and we know that for a fact, because we've checked it with him in person. Twice. They don't even say it the right way in his own local market, but that's how he pronounces it...no other duo in the league says it like us."

The irrelevant stories are one thing...but using a player's name to publicly mock other broadcasters AND an opposing fanbase was absolutely unacceptable. It made me so irritated that I actually turned off the radio in disgust.
 
  • Like
Reactions: guymez
JordanGalhanth said:
Had to bump this thread because of the sheer unprofessionalism that happened on air tonight.

Was listening to the game on my way home, and heard the usual amount of useless trivia instead of calling the game. But then in addition, Jack spent a good 30-40 seconds - during the play, of course - to specifically boast about how he and Bob are the only broadcast duo in the whole league who pronounce Elias Petterson's name the right way. "It's El-EEis, not Elias...and we know that for a fact, because we've checked it with him in person. Twice. They don't even say it the right way in his own local market, but that's how he pronounces it...no other duo in the league says it like us."

The irrelevant stories are one thing...but using a player's name to publicly mock other broadcasters AND an opposing fanbase was absolutely unacceptable. It made me so irritated that I actually turned off the radio in disgust.
Click to expand...

There are so many things in the world to be disgusted by.

But this? This is f*** all.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Austerlitz and Recast
I like Jack and I like the broadcasts.

Rob Brown is highly underrated between periods and post games. I typically will listen to CHED during intermissions instead of watching SNET broadcast, Way more and better content on CHED during the intermissions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MessierII
I like Jack's energy. I like his calls. And he seems very knowledgeable. But he does a bit too much tangenting for a radio broadcast where your whole understanding of what's happening in the game comes from his mouth. He's talking about Matt Benning's high school sweet heart or some baloney while a 2 on 1 is developing that you'll never know about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KYams17
i agree jack is not good! bob is decent but i like reid and rob brown especially brown probably my favorite oilers analyst/media guy too bad he doesn't do more work, i won't be to upset if the oilers go another way in the upcoming local broadcast deal in the next ~2 seasons
 
3aumt5.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: KYams17, The Bored Man, guymez and 2 others
Trizent said:
I like Jack and I like the broadcasts.

Rob Brown is highly underrated between periods and post games. I typically will listen to CHED during intermissions instead of watching SNET broadcast, Way more and better content on CHED during the intermissions.
Click to expand...
You're half right. I like Rob Brown too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nexttothemoon
I like to watch and listen to the opposing teams for their play by play and colour commentary when I'm streaming the Oiler's games... so not only do I not hear Michael's subpar play by play but I also get a view into opposing teams views as well and how they view the Oilers as well as their own players.

Overall I like that way of watching the games although the commentators are obviously a lot less excited when the Oilers score. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: guymez
This was a topic over beers the other day.

Jack fails to paint the picture for listeners. He’s suppose to be our eyes. He gets side tracked. We can hear hockey being played and crowds reacting.

I think he might be good on Tv. But I think for
Years jack worked in the minors wearing two hats, without a Colour guy and it gave him some bad Habits.

My buddy DM him to ask him about it.
Jack says in his broadcasting experience the audience wants flare, background information and a full experience.

So don’t expect much to change.



As for the petersson thing. It’s been a little thing they’ve been playing up for a while now. Jack asked Petersson last season what he prefers and most media haven’t adapted that way. No biggy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom