Absolutely as he should. Jack Edwards reacts to the opposition scoring the same way as when the Bruins score (excitement), which is confusing and angering as a Bruins fan.
Jack Edwards needs to be stopped.
- Thread starter The Senators Guy
- Start date
-
Work is still on-going to rebuild the site styling and features. Please report any issues you may experience so we can look into it. Click Here for Updates
Absolutely as he should. Jack Edwards reacts to the opposition scoring the same way as when the Bruins score (excitement), which is confusing and angering as a Bruins fan.
bert
Registered User
- Nov 11, 2002
- 37,576
- 23,899
68 likes on a comment right on! Well deserved good post.
VoluntaryDom
Formerly DominicBoltsFan / Ⓐ / ✞
I still think anything he said on tonight's game will be hard to compare with 'HEARTS OF LIONS! With the point of the dagger at their throats, they rip it out of Toronto's hand and kill the beast!"
burstnbloom
Registered User
- Mar 10, 2006
- 4,552
- 3,980
The worst of hfboards is when it moralizes about local hockey announcers.
Ivo
Registered User
When I watch my team play, I prefer a homer announcer that is on my side. Also, I want an announcer that gets excited, yells and goes bananas when something big is happening. There is nothing worse than a boring, dull announcers, especially since I usually watch the games in the middle of the night, so I need all the help I can get to stay awake. Jack Edwards is my favorite, if you don't want a homer, why are you watching the game on the Bruins' network? Besides, even though he is a homer, he yells excitedly every time the other team scores. Not many local announcers do that.
If there are so many homer announcers out there, why is a Edwards the one who gets singled out so much? We don’t see threads on other homer announcers as much as we do with him.
I’ll let you guys try to figure it out.
I’ll let you guys try to figure it out.
BigBadBruins7708
Registered User
because Bruins.
The 2 biggest and most vocal fanbases in hockey hate our guts (Toronto, Montreal). So of course they're gonna make thread after thread hating on someone that is a Bruins homer. Complain about it enough and others start buying into it too, especially when they only watch edited clips instead of a full telecast.
The other huge homers (cough cough Steigerwald and Jeanneret) dont get talked about as much because frankly no one cares about them
No, that’s not it. Edwards doesn’t get flack for being a homer, it’s for being an unprofessional lunatic who can’t control his emotions.
What other announcer laughs like a maniac like he did when Jones got hit from behind? The guy is a sociopath.
That rant against the refs in a game in Toronto is a perfect example. Who else does that? Have you ever heard a rant that was so over the top like that from a local broadcaster?
You know who is an even bigger homer? Mickey Redmond for the Wings. Good lord is he a homer, but he’s not out of control like Edwards is. He doesn’t rant and rave and jump up and down when he doesn’t get his way.
I don’t even hate Edwards believe it or not. I think he’s a good broadcaster, but man, he’s so unprofessional.
Beezeral
Registered User
- Mar 1, 2010
- 10,036
- 5,258
There have been fan bases from all across the NHL who have said they hate Edwards. He’s a clown. But like I have said multiple times itt. The Boston fan base wants an over the top clown calling their games. So you are getting exactly what you want and he is doing exactly the job he is asked to do.
Filatov2Kovalev2Bonk
Effortless sexy.
Edwards is more than fine. Compare that to Brownilson here in Ottawa, who have the same monotone until Brown goes "Scramble!" then they make fan fiction about the crowd. Get excited, get homeriffic, get indignant at every perceived slight. You announce for the home team, if you're not a little frothing-at-the-mouth, why are you there?
wintersej
Registered User
Jack calling a non-Bruins game is great. Just an excited dude calling hockey. I can understand how watching him call the Bruins as a non-Bruins fan would be annoying. He does to a better job that most announcers at calling out great stuff by the other team.
Le Magnifique 66
Let's Go Pens
He is a homer and if the bruins fans like him then good for them.
Every team has their homer I guess
Every team has their homer I guess
MasterDecoy
Who took my beer?
This is the guy that compared an ot game seven win against the lower seeded hab to the revolutionary war.
This is a step up is what I'm saying....
This is a step up is what I'm saying....
Mick Riddleton
60% of the time, it works every time
- Apr 24, 2017
- 14,644
- 16,111
Yeah he would have a great career if he picked on everything Bruin as a regional play by play guy employed by NESN. What's next, lets pick on the cab drivers or MacDonald servers in Boston?
burstnbloom
Registered User
- Mar 10, 2006
- 4,552
- 3,980
Is Jack any worse than the Panthers pbp guy and his cry baby sidekick ? Jack is nuts but he is well prepared and probably knows as much about the panther line up than the 5000 fans that go to the games.
sabremike
Kemonito superfan
When I am king anyone who compares Jack Edwards (who is awful going back to his days of destroying USMNT telecasts with Ty Keough) to a legend like RJ will be tossed off a tall building to the ground below.
sabremike
Kemonito superfan
And for RJ: Even though he has been repeatedly asked to do a national broadcast he always turns it down because he bleeds blue and gold and doesn't think it would be fair to the other team. So basically while he's a homer he's also an honorable guy.
I of course do think he went over the top, as he is certainly prone to do, but some of the comments in this thread are frustrating. On the whole, I like him as a commentator because he gets genuinely excited about ANY good hockey play, regardless of the team. He's even been known pretty regularly to criticize his own team/compliment the other. Its just that the only clips that get attention are the ones where he lets his emotion get the better of him (which is perhaps more than should happen, but still not as common as people make them out to be).
Also, he would be the first to admit he never played the game and tends to caveat a lot of what he says noting he is just a fan/bystander.
He does go overboard, to the point that I've even said "oh cmon now Jack" on more than a few occasions, but his passion for the game makes for good entertainment most times. Dont see his overall body of work as a bad thing given that he is a REGIONAL pbp announcer.
Also, he would be the first to admit he never played the game and tends to caveat a lot of what he says noting he is just a fan/bystander.
He does go overboard, to the point that I've even said "oh cmon now Jack" on more than a few occasions, but his passion for the game makes for good entertainment most times. Dont see his overall body of work as a bad thing given that he is a REGIONAL pbp announcer.
