pld459666
Registered User
I get it only superstars that won championships only get their number retired.
No, but players that have done extraordinary things for the franchise which Zucc has not
I get it only superstars that won championships only get their number retired.
I don’t know what’s more shocking, the idea or the fact it wasn’t Webster who started this thread.
Gilbert, Hadfield, Ratelle, Howell, Bathgate and Giacomin never won a Cup with the Rangers but that's the type of impact you are looking for if a player is honored this way.
Zuccarello is nowhere close that that
I know we never won. But Zucc meant more than anyone has besides Lundqvist the last decade. Pure heart, and soul guy, that gave his all. I hope one day we can retire #36 for all he’s done. I mean we can still sign him in the offseason but is he worthy if it?
It's going to be weird for the fans to see another player wearing #36 though.
And Jed Ortmeyer and Sandy McCarthy.Perhaps if it was based on the extra effort award, he won it 3 times. But then Callahan's number should also be retired.
I would retire Girardi's number before I retire Zuccarello's
That guy was something else. I wouldn’t retire his number — but boy was he something before age caught up to him.
Neither would I, but I would retire no 5 for Girardi before I even think of retiring no 36 for Zuccarello
For sure: 5, 18 and 24 before 36 AFAIC, though 5 is the most worthy of the four IMHO.
None of them are worthy.