norrisnick
The best...
- Apr 14, 2005
- 30,571
- 15,716
I'm pretty sure I answered any questions explicitly directed at me. Page 96, if you want to roll back. Answers are there.I have repeatedly said that I'm not a SC counter, nor a strict trophy counter and that McDavid could potentially pass crosby all time even without a SC so perhaps your comments are misplaced here.
The reason that a SC for McDavid isn't necessary is because I do this weird thing of putting players in context to their surroundings, eras, team makeup, injuries, peaks, valley ect.
I also apply the same lens as equally as possible to all players not just situational charts that I like and call ones I don't prefer as much bogus or some such BS.
There was also a couple of questions I asked you quite a while ago in this thread that you avoided answering but honestly I don't even want to waste my time brining them up again as your non answer was an answer to anyone paying attention.
My comments aren't misplaced. Don't be surprised if Beliveau is brought up when one side of a debate loves to dangle cup wins around. You pointing out the absurdity of the logical application thereof kind of nullifies the original claims? That's exactly why Beliveau is mentioned. Because his cups, as well as Sid's cups, don't mean shit when comparing individual players. And if they do? Well, then Beliveau trumps Crosby and no one on that side seems to want to make that claim.
Last edited: