Ok, I’m going to try to explain this to you as nicely and as simple as I can….
You can’t match to a 18 year old Crosby with an 18 year old McDavid. Why? That match up never happened, it doesn’t exist. The only match ups we have are the ones where their careers happen to overlap. The head to head match ups were discussed and posted, and of course…you go..”UMMM YOU CANT COMPARE 18 YEAR OLD MCDAVID WITH CROSBY! HES TO OLD!!” But that’s literally the ONLY choice we have.
In the head to head match ups, we have NO OTHER WAY of doing it. So while you love throwing out your big words like “disingenuous.” And complain that I’m doing a “bit.” I’m literally reading stats
Also, Stop with the “old” argument. McDavid hasn’t peaked yet and Crosby was still very much considered one of the top players in the world still. It’s not doing Crosby ANY disservice to compare him to McDavid in 2017 and 2018, you just see it that way because you are emotional and get frustrated when you can’t have an argument go your way.
I hope this helped you.