Wallet Inspector
Registered User
- Jan 19, 2013
- 6,227
- 5,733
How do you compare the two Canadian superstars?
It's like the Bure vs Kucherov debate... one is a Lamborghini with all flash no substance (McDavid) and one is a reliable winner and leader (Sid).
I mean when you are having conversation in where he ranks in like the top 10 all time in NHL history....to place him in the top 5 I don't think it is ridiculous to expect him to need to win one. Not saying it is his fault they haven't won...but it objectively matters when you are talking about a legacy for a player like this.Are we still holding it against mcdavid that the Oilers haven't won a cup with him?
I feel like I’m in a Crosby vs. Toews thread from 2013.This is simple. Want points, highlights, Art Trophies?
Take McDavid
Want leadership, your team performance to level up, Stanley Cups?
Take Crosby.
I understand the perception. I think it's bullshit though.I mean when you are having conversation in where he ranks in like the top 10 all time in NHL history....to place him in the top 5 I don't think it is ridiculous to expect him to need to win one. Not saying it is his fault they haven't won...but it objectively matters when you are talking about a legacy for a player like this.
Yes, because it somehow proves that he's not a "leader."Are we still holding it against mcdavid that the Oilers haven't won a cup with him?
Yeah, first they compared him to Ovi, then Toews, Then Kane, Then McDavid.. who's next?I feel like I’m in a Crosby vs. Toews thread from 2013.
What exactly is this based on?This is simple. Want points, highlights, Art Trophies?
Take McDavid
Want leadership, your team performance to level up, Stanley Cups?
Take Crosby.
Well I don't think I really have to answer on that question, but maybe check what his teams(Team Canada and Pittsburgh) have achieved with him as a captain, then after that see some player polls, interviews and opinions. That'll help to understand why one of the all-time best leaders is a good leader.What exactly is this based on?
That went right over your head.Yeah, first they compared him to Ovi, then Toews, Then Kane, Then McDavid.. who's next?
Absolutely Horrible take considering Mcdavid just became the first skater in the 21st century to win the Conn Symthe despite his team losing.It's like the Bure vs Kucherov debate... one is a Lamborghini with all flash no substance (McDavid) and one is a reliable winner and leader (Sid).