bobholly39
Registered User
- Mar 10, 2013
- 23,172
- 16,471
Do this years oilers have the same success with Crosby in whatever year he was at his best?
Do the oilers have better playoff success in any previous years with the best version of Crosby?
Answer is no.
Mcdavid is the better, more dominant player of the two
By default, that puts him on a different tier
Those are two extremely loaded questions and one extremely dumb and oversimplified answer. It's definitely not that easy.
Oilers may have had same/better success with Crosby. Or maybe they do worst. It's impossible to say. Way too many layers to it.
If you're trying to prove some point - you're definitely not doing it right.
Also - the poster I replied to was saying "voters says McDavid wins the poll". And all I said was no - he doesn't. Majority of voters are saying they are on the same tier.