The Rangers have already restocked the cupboard starting last offseason. They turned Stepan into two players. They turned Mac into 3-4 depending on how the draft goes and how you think that trade went down in terms of value. They turned Nash into 2-3 players, not counting Spooner and the other two cones. Grabner into 1-2 players.
Most of those players will be busts or dime a dozen crap NHLers. The two late first rounders and the Devils' second have about a 30% chance of one of them turning into a top-6F or top-4D. Among Rykov, Hajek and Lindgren, I'll be happy if one of them turns into a top-4 defenseman. People always say, 'but what if someone surprises?' but for every surprise there are dozens of busts. In the last quarter century, only one defenseman (McDonagh) surprised us to become a star when we expected less at the time of the acquisition. Now think of the dozens who disappointed. Even among Lias and Chytil, it would be a good outcome if one of them turns into an impact player and the other into a role player.
Realistically, if the Rangers get 3 impact (top-6F or top-4D) players from the 2017 and 2018 drafts plus the prospects they acquired, that's good progress. Problem is that they already lost 3 top-shelf player (McD and Nash) and one way or another will lose MZA and Shatty by the time the kids are ready. If Chytil turns into MZA (talent, not style), Lias into Nash, Hajek/Rykov into McDonagh (huge surprise if that happens), first rounder into Shatty, another first or second into Grabner, another pick into JT Miller, we are still only where the team was before February (just younger)... and that team was out of the playoffs. And the outcomes for each of these players/picks is extremely unlikely to be as good as what I just wrote above.
The rebuilding must go on. They should run another firesale this season involving MZA, Shatty, Spoon, Names, possibly Staal who might have value with less term left and the cap going up.
- MZA for 2019 and 2020 firsts plus a B prospect (e.g., another Rykov).
- Shatty for #1 and a B prospect.
- Spoon for a second and a B prospect.
- Names for a second and a B prospect.
- Staal for #3.