If McDavid does not win a Cup, but ends up with better regular seasons, would you consider him better than Sid?

[North Cole]

This is another thread where many here defending McDavid have probably never played competitive sports.

Cups matter more then anything. Ask a player if the Stanley Cup doesn’t matter.

It’s like playing bot lobbies in call of duty compared to playing for 100k against the best in the world and coming out on top.

Sid has three Cups. Until McDavid touches that he’s always in Sids rear view.

"Many in here have never played competitive sports"

Best analogy same poster can come up with:
"Playing vs bots in video games"

Put the Cheetos down lmao. Regular season doesn't matter to guys like Chris Kunitz and their all time ranking because they were just another dude on the ice. Regular season does separate players when you get into the top of the all time list, there's a reason no one on the crazy Habs dynasty is ranked above Gretzky all time. 10 Art Ross and many Harts actually does make a difference.