Toggle sidebar

If Draisaitl wins the Hart, does he join MacKinnon and Kucherov in the "2nd Best player since the 2015" discussion.

Is Draisaitl right there with Mac and Kucherov in ranking the best players since 2015?

  • No, even if wins the Hart

    Votes: 5 20.8%

  • Yes, if he wins the Hart

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Yes, he was already there

    Votes: 19 79.2%

  • No, he is above them

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Total voters
    24

daver

Registered User
Apr 4, 2003
25,809
5,677
281
Visit site
A lack of a Cup/playing with McDavid may have kept Draisaitl a bit below Mack and Kucherov despite having numbers that argubly place him right there with them. For the first time in his career, he is clearly having a better season than McDavid.

Is he right there with those two in ranking the best players since 2015?
 
having no cups is a team thing. Drasaitl has impressive playoff numbers. Kucherov has 2 covid cups where one in which they circumvented the cap, MacKinnon has 1 cup which seems a bit underwelming since Colorado has been a contender for a number of years.
 
IMO he is still #4 but 2-4 is a close group.

McDavid
Mack/Kuch/Drai

Regardless of who wins this year that's how it will be
 
centipede2233 said:
having no cups is a team thing. Drasaitl has impressive playoff numbers. Kucherov has 2 covid cups where one in which they circumvented the cap, MacKinnon has 1 cup which seems a bit underwelming since Colorado has been a contender for a number of years.
Click to expand...
1 cup is never underwhelming in a 30+ team league. Winning. 1 is very hard
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trade and AvsFan29
centipede2233 said:
having no cups is a team thing. Drasaitl has impressive playoff numbers. Kucherov has 2 covid cups where one in which they circumvented the cap, MacKinnon has 1 cup which seems a bit underwelming since Colorado has been a contender for a number of years.
Click to expand...

I would agree it's a bit of a tossup between them for best playoff performer but Draisaitl did not deliver much past the 2nd round last year, most notably in the SCF. In 2023, he had one assist after the Oilers were up 2-0 against the Knights. He has been like MacKinnon before 2022, racking up big point totals in high scoring games but not delivering in keys moments to advance his team.

Painting the Bolts' Cup wins as anything other than deserving isn't reasonable. They had two SCF appearances besides the two Cups and were knocking on the door in other years too.

What is more tangible is that Mac and Kucherov hit a level last year in the regular season that Draisaitl has not hit.
 
daver said:
I would agree it's a bit of a tossup between them for best playoff performer but Draisaitl did not deliver much past the 2nd round last year, most notably in the SCF. In 2023, he had one assist after the Oilers were up 2-0 against the Knights. He has been like MacKinnon before 2022, racking up big point totals in high scoring games but not delivering in keys moments to advance his team.

Painting the Bolts' Cup wins as anything other than deserving isn't reasonable. They had two SCF appearances besides the two Cups and were knocking on the door in other years too.

What is more tangible is that Mac and Kucherov hit a level last year in the regular season that Draisaitl has not hit.
Click to expand...
Every player looks bad if you only cherry pick the games they played poorly in.
 
ijuka said:
Every player looks bad if you only cherry pick the games they played poorly in.
Click to expand...

Let's put it this way. I would not give Draisaitl an advantage over them based on his playoff PPG.

The Oilers have run and gunned their way to more wins than Tbay and the Avs have. When the Oilers played more of a defensive game to get farther along, and separated Drai and McDavid at ES, Draisaitl's numbers went down.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: The Nuge
How many more 50goal/50 assist seasons, 100 point seasons, Art Ross, and Hart trophies is it gonna take for Draisaitl to be regarded at the same level as Kucherov and MacKinnon? The fact is, he’s already there.

And it might be unpopular, but I think he’s at the same level as a prime Crosby, Ovechkin, and Malkin. The numbers are there, especially if he captures another Hart and Ross by the end of this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pass the Saitl Sauce and The Nuge
TheGuiminator said:
How many more 50goal/50 assist seasons, 100 point seasons, Art Ross, and Hart trophies is it gonna take for Draisaitl to be regarded at the same level as Kucherov and MacKinnon? The fact is, he’s already there.

And it might be unpopular, but I think he’s at the same level as a prime Crosby, Ovechkin, and Malkin. The numbers are there, especially if he captures another Hart and Ross by the end of this season.
Click to expand...

Based on what?
 
Draisaitl is on an 18 game scoring streak, the longest this season
he's recorded his 6th 100 point season, only Crosby and McDavid have had as many
he's 1 goal away from his 4th 50G-50A season, the only active player in the NHL to do this 4 times

I'd say he's right there
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trade
I don’t see the point in voter awards affecting someone’s opinion of a player. It wouldn’t change how good his season is or how good he’s been the past 7-8 years. I think he’s always been in that group, though I’ve tended to prefer the other two. Also, I think he was also clearly better than McDavid in his previous Hart season.
 
I prefer Mackinnon but I have to give the man credit, he's been in that tier this entire time; he's better this season too. Wouldn't trade Mackinnon for him but if it happened, I'd be okay with it sentiments aside.
 
CantHaveTkachev said:
Draisaitl is on an 18 game scoring streak, the longest this season
he's recorded his 6th 100 point season, only Crosby and McDavid have had as many
he's 1 goal away from his 4th 50G-50A season, the only active player in the NHL to do this 4 times

I'd say he's right there
Click to expand...
Over their last 18 games (since January 26th):
Mackinnon: 18-8-20-28
Draisaitl: 18-13-14-27
Mackinnon has scored more points than Draisaitl over the scoring streak.

Draisaitl had a PPG of 1.51 before the streak and over his scoring streak he has a PPG of 1.5. He is actually scoring at a sligthly lower pace by the numbers.
 
Last edited:
TheGuiminator said:
How many more 50goal/50 assist seasons, 100 point seasons, Art Ross, and Hart trophies is it gonna take for Draisaitl to be regarded at the same level as Kucherov and MacKinnon? The fact is, he’s already there.

And it might be unpopular, but I think he’s at the same level as a prime Crosby, Ovechkin, and Malkin. The numbers are there, especially if he captures another Hart and Ross by the end of this season.
Click to expand...
He hasn't done anything to prove he's on prime Crosby or OV's level.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Regal and geebster
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom