I totally agree that players who run around just looking for that big hit are awful for the game. Hate them. Total lack of respect for fellow pros. Absolutely no place for a guy looking to injure others. And there are quite a few around still.
That said, the hit on Sauer wasnt bad. Just bad luck. He didnt hit Sauer in the head or from behind. Sauer wasnt engaged with anyone else at the time. He just went backward and hit his head.
The gloating was the bad part. Gross.
I don't really agree. I don't like Dion's hit on Sauer at all, think it was pretty disgusting.
I want the big hits from my team, and there are many dangerous hits that I do not mind. Take Gudas hit on Stahlberg for example. Scott Stevens. Heck even many of Darius Kasparitis hits. Kronwall's hits.
I've played a lot of hockey myself. Its a physical sport that in many senses can be compared to boxing for example. If you get the puck in your own end, and skates with it up ice, its part of the sport that a defensemen within the rules of the game can skate against you and hit you hard. Be it that its going to be a helluva collision if two players moving at 20 mph run into each other.
Its also something any player on the ice are in control of. In some situations its harder than in others, but you control the fact if you are going to be hit by Gudas or Stevens or Kronwall. If you as a forward in hockey have the puck and try to challenge Kasparitis by beating him wide, you know, there is a risk that he is going to destroy you. And that risk is part of the game just like its to be knocked out in boxing.
But -- in the game of hockey today -- the game is just too fast for any player to always -- at any time -- be able to protect themselves. Bouncing pucks. A player being in a situation players usually are not in. And what not really. All kind of odd situations a player ends up in here and there. I don't at all think you can compare these situations. Mainly because the target in one category has a chance to control their own fate, the targets in the other category has no reasonable chance to do the same.
Sauer is hit in a situation that is completely unique. A few feets inside the blueline a defender is coming at him out of no-where with absolutely full speed. You can watch 100 games and never see that situation. The puck is bouncing a lot on him. And he is if pressured by another player. To in that situation completely steam roll a player just because you can is IMO very dirty.
And its just not true to claim that Phaneuf did it just because he could and we would want our players to do it too if they just could do it but they can't. That is not even remotely true. If all players ran around looking for hits like this all the time, we would see them all the time. Just come in with full speed any time 3-4 players are fighting around the boards and you will find a target to really destroy like every other game. For a while in Philly Mike Richards used to destroy players on a regular basis in a certain situation. He would back-check at full speed. Then if the other team took the puck to the net were they literary braked to stay in the scoring area, and then ended up with the puck or had just had the puck (so close in time that its not interference), MR would completely run over anyone he could. Often hitting them into the post etc. I think he made like 5-10 hits like this during a 6 month period PO included. Than he had a lot of injuries and stopped. But I mean, you almost never see anyone do those hits. You could do them 3-4 times per game probably if you wanted too, but players don't go there.