How many teams would Thomas Harley be a #1D on?

[SeanMoneyHands]

This guy is good, real good. We saw it at 4 Nation's and again this playoffs. He's a legit #1D today, but plays behind Heiskanen in Dallas. So how many teams would he be a #1D on right now?

 

[Garbageyuk]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

 

[TheKingSlayer]

He'd be a #1 on all the 'no' teams if they didn't already have their own. Same situation he's in right now.

 

[ref19]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

what?

 

[Garbageyuk]

what?

What.

 

[ref19]

What.

You had Minnesota as a yes. Should be a no.

 

[Garbageyuk]

You had Minnesota as a yes. Should be a no.

Why? He’s all around better than any of their D.

 

[Dynamite Time]

Guys only 23 and saw him recently on the AHL Stars… give him a minute and he’ll be even better.

edit - didn’t catch it myself till earlier after the win but even with Heiskanen out till recently he’s got (4g - 7a) 11 pts in 13 games this postseason, guy has stepped up.

 

[ref19]

Why? He’s all around better than any of their D.

That's a bold opinion.

 

[Garbageyuk]

That's a bold opinion.

No it really isn’t. He blows every MIN D out of the water in terms of production, and he’s as good as any defensively except maybe Brodin, who was a 20 point guy this year. I’d like to hear who you think is even close and why?

Edit: this guy seems to think the laugh react button suffices as an argument

 

[ref19]

No it really isn’t. He blows every MIN D out of the water in terms of production, and he’s as good as any defensively except maybe Brodin, who was a 20 point guy this year. I’d like to hear who you think is even close and why?

Hilarious. Brock Faber.

 

[Garbageyuk]

Hilarious. Brock Faber.

Well? I’m waiting for the how and why?

 

[Garbageyuk]

Hilarious. Brock Faber.

Hilarious. Harley has the vastly superior production, possession metrics, and analytics. He’s better both offensively and defensively.

Faber is an offensive D who put up 29 points lmao.

 

[Thallis]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

I'd have Harley over Hamilton, Josi, Sergachev, Theodore/Hanifin/Pietrangelo, and Carlsson at this point. Maybes for me would be Hedman, Slavin, and Morissey

 

[boredmale]

 

[MBTendy]

This season?

Chi: yes
Ana: yes
Bos: maybe
Car: no
Col: no
Cgy: yes
Buf: no
Cbj: no
Edm: no
Det: maybe
Nj: no
Min: yes
La: maybe
Fla: yes
Nyi: maybe
Nsh: no
Sj: yes
Mtl: maybe
Nyr: no
Stl: maybe
Sea: yes
Ott: no
Phi: yes
Uta: no
Van: no
Tbl: no
Pit: yes
Wpg: no
Vgk: no
Tor: yes
Wsh: no

10/32, so less than a 1/3. If you give him all the maybes, which is not at all clear-cut, it’s 16/32. He’s an average to high end #2 as it stands right now.

Awful list lol.

 

[MrLunatik]

One team

Because you cannot play for more than 1 team at a time.