Dryden-Tretiak... i dunno how old you are, but thousands of voices have put them in convo as -at least - near each other, same tier guys.Dryden is not, for me.
We're gonna go ahead and make this official. Voting for this round will open next Friday, October 11 instead, and the OP will be edited to reflect this.Lots of interesting avenues of discussion today... me and @Professor What are not quite satisfied that we're going to be able to flesh all of it out by Sunday.
How much appetite is there for this opening vote's discussion to be extended for another week? Seeing how it is the first vote, we want to make sure we get this 'right'... but if people are set to vote, then we'll be set too.
That's all well and good. Call me the Hair Splitter then. Tretiak is a tier better for me.Dryden-Tretiak... i dunno how old you are, but thousands of voices have put them in convo as -at least - near each other, same tier guys.
To kick Dryden out of a club and admit Tretiak is to split hairs.
Terry Sawchuk, for reasons already mentionned in this thread (slight distrust about his peak due to being achieved on easy mode, back 3-quarters of his career as a below-average starter).Here's a question.
Does anyone here have either Tretiak or Dryden top 6? In my opinion - there seems to be a pretty clear top 6.
It might make sense to add the top 6 to the final list after the first vote, especially if we're going an extra week, assuming the voting comes out with a clear gap for the 6.
If anyone does think Dryden or Tretiak should break up the top 6 - I'd love to hear the argument, and I'd love to hear how high you'd slot them, and who goes down to 7th and/or 8th.
Disciples?That's all well and good. Call me the Hair Splitter then. Tretiak is a tier better for me.
One unrelated note, but just out of curiosity...Brodeur, Belfour, Nabokov, etc. etc. trace their roots to Tretiak and base their game on Tretiak.
Who are the Dryden disciples out there?
If you are all ears... Sawchuk was netminding a dynasty of Howe, Kelly, Lindsay, and Plante played BEHIND Harvey, Richard and Beliveau, among others (a boatload of HOFers).If anyone does think Dryden or Tretiak should break up the top 6 - I'd love to hear the argument, and I'd love to hear how high you'd slot them, and who goes down to 7th and/or 8th.