HF Habs: HF Habs: 2024 Habs Prospect rankings #18

[habsterr]

Kidney is too weak and frail.

 

[McGuires Corndog]

Kidney is the new Ben Maxwell, I cannot see him make the NHL because of his frame.

Maxwell put up 58 points in his 20yr old AHL rookie season (0.79ppg)

Kidney did 20pts in 65 games in his. (0.31ppg).

Comparing him to Maxwell is actually way too flattering.

 

[Treb]

Is it known how his summer training is going?

Shouldn't a prospect in Kidney's position have every incentive to work out properly?

I don't think the workout is the whole problem. Seems like one of these guys who struggle to put on mass.

 

[ryan callahan]

Rohrer at 3 votes is absolutely embarrassing. Should be winning this one in a landslide. He produced well with a top NLA team as a 19 yo.

 

[habsterr]

Rohrer at 3 votes is absolutely embarrassing. Should be winning this one in a landslide. He produced well with a top NLA team as a 19 yo.

Agreed very underrated.

 

[JianYang]

Rohrer at 3 votes is absolutely embarrassing. Should be winning this one in a landslide. He produced well with a top NLA team as a 19 yo.

Again, that speaks to the depth of the pool more than anything. No matter how you do your rankings, you are going to have some guys ranked in the 20s that still have decent prospects to be an nhl player.

You may be more bullish on rohrer than most, but I guarantee you that he would be far higher on a prospect pool from a few years ago.

 

[Trabdy2]

Tuch

Add Harris

 

[Trabdy2]

Rohrer at 3 votes is absolutely embarrassing. Should be winning this one in a landslide. He produced well with a top NLA team as a 19 yo.

I have Rohrer next after Tuch. Tuch is signed and I think he has a decent shot at making it somewhere in a bottom six role.

Rohrer and Eriksson are only 2 months apart in age, despite the difference in draft year. I have Rohrer above Eriksson for the time being as I feel he's shown more so far, but I am intrigued by Eriksson too. I'm excited to see what Eriksson will do this year.