Jim Bob
RIP RJ
It is more than a few impulsive or stupid decisions. He has not made a good decision yet when it comes to the GM or coaching hires in over a decade as owner.I wanted to address this one separately.
I’m going assume this question is implying he hasn’t hired an experienced GM so he can control who he brings in. But lets look at the facts, the history of his hires and how things played out.
1) LaFontaine/Murray -> We started the 13-14 season with Regier as GM. Then in November, Pegula impulsively hires Patty as POHO based on a single dinner they had together. Essentially fanboying over him. Patty gets full control of hockey ops and hires Murray to be his GM.
They very quickly start butting heads on the direction of the rebuild/tank approach. Pegula has to step back in and pick a side. He goes with Murray’s vision which leads to Patty’s resignation. We don’t really hear much from Pegula again after that until he fires Murray.
2) Botts -> this is the only GM hire that came from a “normal” search process, with the NHL front office giving him (Pegula )guidance. But as you posted, Pegula was boxed out from being involved during his tenure. We may disgree on what he means by “involved” but we both know this was a thing.
3) Krueger/Adams/“flat management” structure -> somehow Krueger had Pegula convinced he found his McDermott for the Sabres. He was given a lot of front office power but had no relevant GM experience (plus he sucked as a coach). He gets paired up with Adams, who the owner trusts but also has no relevant GM experience.
It was supposed to mimic the Bills set up. It would be funny if it wasn't so disastrous. Yet another macro decision that blew up in Pegula’s face like the LaFontaine hire did.
4) Adams becomes sole GM -> Adams flies down one weekend to meet with the Pegulas in Florida. This was in the middle of the 18gm losing streak. He goes down there to sell them on; (a) firing Krueger, (b) go back to her traditional management structure and (c) on his plan o rebuild the team. He clearly sold them on all 3 things and we’re in year 3 of his plan.
———————————————————————————-
I don’t know how anyone can look at the above and see an owner who is manipulating and controlling things. As opposed to someone who has made a few impulsive and/or stupid decisions because he’s easily talked into things. That’s why I’ve always felt the idea that he is some sort of Machiavellian operator in the shadows to be so ridiculous. He’s an about as slick as tar and is easily led, especially if he is a fanboy of or trusts someone.
Whether the reason why Pegula has consistently hired rookie GMs, and mostly rookie head coaches, is just that he is really, really bad at identifying quality candidates, he is unwilling to pay top dollar to land a candidate with a proven record, or he wants more input than a person with a resume and options would allow, it doesn't really matter to me.
None of the GMs that Pegula has hired and then fired have as yet been given a second chance.
Lindy Ruff is the last head coach that Pegula fired who has gotten an NHL head coaching job since.
And then you have all the turmoil and turnover you've seen in the PSE/One Buffalo leadership, and it points to that Pegula may have gotten really lucky with the McDermott hire and McDermott pushing for the Beane hire.
Pegula being really, really bad at identifying the right people is the main reason why I think he needs someone with NHL experience, whether that is a POHO or a Senior Advisor, to help him make these decisions. He has proven over the past decade that he is not good at this.