Habs Playoffs player evaluations
- Thread starter HabsRealist
- Start date
Desharnais was by far the worst player of both teams on the ice thats all I will say... If this guy get PP over Eller or Galchenyuk next year, I dont know what I will do..
Tinordi will be good but he is still too raw..
Tinordi will be good but he is still too raw..
Thats a douchy comment, why would you want Tinordi to fail? He's a prospect, we should all be encouraging him!!!!! Like i mean the kid has pretty good potentiel. If this kid flops tough, the habs are really in big trouble!
Ezpz
No mad pls
- Apr 16, 2013
- 15,664
- 13,968
Maybe not next year, but he will be a NHL top-6 defenceman, not a single doubt about it.
Good: Bourque, Galchenyuk, Gallagher and Subban. Future looks great.
Average: Halpern, Plekanec
Bad: most of them
Worst:
Desharnais: this is really the first time that I criticize him. Damn, he's so bad. In the interview, he kept saying that he will play better the next game. And it never happens.
Moen: useless guy. His contract length pisses me even more.
Markov: I did like Markov very much. But in the last few weeks, Markov was horrible. Beside Gill, I don't remember a D in Habs jersey who's that slow. It's so obvious. He's not a liability on D yet, but he's not far from it. Markov is not the worst player, but he's definitely the player that disappoints me the most.
Average: Halpern, Plekanec
Bad: most of them
Worst:
Desharnais: this is really the first time that I criticize him. Damn, he's so bad. In the interview, he kept saying that he will play better the next game. And it never happens.
Moen: useless guy. His contract length pisses me even more.
Markov: I did like Markov very much. But in the last few weeks, Markov was horrible. Beside Gill, I don't remember a D in Habs jersey who's that slow. It's so obvious. He's not a liability on D yet, but he's not far from it. Markov is not the worst player, but he's definitely the player that disappoints me the most.
boris4c
Quid infantes sumus.
TennisMenace
Registered User
This. Very few guys to be impressed with. The 48 game season made our season look better. We would have faded to 8th had it been 82.
Tinordi was pretty terrible but people used to say that about Chara when he first started as well...
Impressed:
- Gallagher
- Galchenyuk
- Bourque
- Subban
- White
- Prust
- Halpern
Neutral:
- Price (had some good and bad moments, lost us Game 1, stole us Game 2, but will need to be good more consistently when the team is ready to make a bigger push)
- Plekanec (played fine, was steady, would be nice to see a bit of fire out of him at times, but you also can't really fault him for anything)
- Pacioretty (guy was kinda useless, but playing with a separated shoulder sucks, especially for someone that is supposed to use his size to leverage scoring opportunitites)
- Gionta (getting a lot of hate, but did what he could with one functional arm)
- Eller (if he had played more, I feel he would have been bumped up one category, really like what he showed this season)
- Tinordi (he had some rough moments, but lets remember that not all rookies can step in with <10 games NHL experience and excel in the playoffs like Subban)
- Markov (almost disappointed, but can't bump him down after seeing him play a full season with no injuries, hopefully a regular off-season will bring us more of the Markov we saw in Jan/Feb)
- Armstrong (played his role just fine)
- Budaj (tough to come in under those circumstances, miss a floater goal in OT, then be exposed to whatever Game 5 was, glad we have a solid backup signed for another few years)
Disappointed:
- Diaz/Gorges/Bouilion (these three vets needed to contribute more on the back end, especially with a rookie like Tinordi in the top 6, while I'm a bit skeptical of Diaz for the longterm, I still really like Gorges and Bouillion is fine for another year)
- Desharnais (I think he's a solid player, but he really showed nothing against Ottawa aside from a few decent plays here and there, which sucks because after Game 1 we lost a lot of our offense and he is specifically the guy that needed to step up, but instead he got even more invisible... not opposed to trading him if Galchenyuk takes it up a notch next year)
- Ryder (didn't seem to care that much, he's always a treat when he's scoring goals, but this is the Ryder I remember from his last year here that no one really missed, don't think he'll be re-signed)
- Moen (doesn't need to be a star, but would be nice if he was playing more like White/Prust, or at least like Armstrong... I hope he's not just mailing it in at this point in his career with 3 more years on his contract)
- Gallagher
- Galchenyuk
- Bourque
- Subban
- White
- Prust
- Halpern
Neutral:
- Price (had some good and bad moments, lost us Game 1, stole us Game 2, but will need to be good more consistently when the team is ready to make a bigger push)
- Plekanec (played fine, was steady, would be nice to see a bit of fire out of him at times, but you also can't really fault him for anything)
- Pacioretty (guy was kinda useless, but playing with a separated shoulder sucks, especially for someone that is supposed to use his size to leverage scoring opportunitites)
- Gionta (getting a lot of hate, but did what he could with one functional arm)
- Eller (if he had played more, I feel he would have been bumped up one category, really like what he showed this season)
- Tinordi (he had some rough moments, but lets remember that not all rookies can step in with <10 games NHL experience and excel in the playoffs like Subban)
- Markov (almost disappointed, but can't bump him down after seeing him play a full season with no injuries, hopefully a regular off-season will bring us more of the Markov we saw in Jan/Feb)
- Armstrong (played his role just fine)
- Budaj (tough to come in under those circumstances, miss a floater goal in OT, then be exposed to whatever Game 5 was, glad we have a solid backup signed for another few years)
Disappointed:
- Diaz/Gorges/Bouilion (these three vets needed to contribute more on the back end, especially with a rookie like Tinordi in the top 6, while I'm a bit skeptical of Diaz for the longterm, I still really like Gorges and Bouillion is fine for another year)
- Desharnais (I think he's a solid player, but he really showed nothing against Ottawa aside from a few decent plays here and there, which sucks because after Game 1 we lost a lot of our offense and he is specifically the guy that needed to step up, but instead he got even more invisible... not opposed to trading him if Galchenyuk takes it up a notch next year)
- Ryder (didn't seem to care that much, he's always a treat when he's scoring goals, but this is the Ryder I remember from his last year here that no one really missed, don't think he'll be re-signed)
- Moen (doesn't need to be a star, but would be nice if he was playing more like White/Prust, or at least like Armstrong... I hope he's not just mailing it in at this point in his career with 3 more years on his contract)
Once again Andrei Markov tomas plekanec and carey price proved they cant raise the level of their game in the playoffs , whether its game 1 or 40 or 62 of the season or a playoff game you always get the same stuff
Users who are viewing this thread
Latest posts
-
-
HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #94: "We know what we are, but know not what we may be." (86 Viewers)- Latest: Gustave
-
-
-
