Finishing in the top 3 would be nice, but there is an abundance of high end talent available in the top 10-12. I may be in the distinct minority here, but I think the quality of this draft is somewhat skewered by the quality of the top 10-15 players. Once you get past those notable players I don't see this draft as being that much better (or worse) than the many drafts that will have preceded the 2023 draft. Draft in the top ten, but outside of the top 3, we should still be able to get an impact player. Perhaps not generational, nor exceptional, but nonetheless, a player that can substantially add to our growing nucleus of young talent.
Look at Brayden Point, Victor Hedman, and Nikita Kucherov. Heck, even Stamkos.
We don’t have a single player who compares to them. Maybe Caufield one day might be a lethal and reliable goal scorer like Stamkos. But otherwise, we need a lot more than good enough. The Habs have busted on the last three top10 picks (Galchenyuk, Sergachev->Drouin, and Kotkaniemi) and have very little to show for it today. Slafkovsky was drafted with the massive caveat that it was a bad draft cuvée at the high-end and we shouldn’t expect a star out of him.
So when will we get star players? This is the year to tank. I don’t think this team can endure another season of losing. MSL will sooner retire than keep digging his W-L record down for some nebulous future success that might not ever show.
We have very good pieces like Guhle and Suzuki, we need star talent and we need it badly. This is the year.
If we can pick up PLD and an instant impact player from the 2023 draft I’d be blown away. It’s the kind of manoeuvre that would set us up for years to come.