GDT: Habs @ Leafs - 7pm - Sportsnet

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/

notbias

Registered User
Feb 16, 2017
11,187
9,400
You'd like to see more than half a season of Domi and Matthews together? If that's what you mean than I agree completely.

Yes, I'd like to see them together longer before I call them a good duo.

They've been great in their time together though.

Marner's first contract - didn't he start out playing on a line with Bozak and JVR? Two experienced vets who were better offensively than defensively, and ideal situation for Marner to put up points and a far cry from him proving he can drive a line. The same goes for him playing with JT later who had already established himself as one of the best players in the world, not clear who was driving what at that point.

Marner led our team in points during his contract year.

If we want to question if Marner was a driver during that year, I question who was driving the line for Matthews last year.

Maybe Domi and Marner were driving the line with Matthews and he was the passenger?

Domi got more points than Marner in these playoffs for a fraction of the cost. I know you love pumping up your boy Marner but you'd do better to not even bring up the last two playoff series cause Marner was a massive disappointment in both.

Marner sucked these playoffs, no complaints with that statement, Domi wasn't good either though.

If I'm the GM, he needs to show that he can play like a superstar in the playoffs before I agree to another contract that pays him like a superstar.

He has shown that, our board just ignores it.

If you added consistently to that, I'd agree.

And all our stars need to.

Pretty much anyone who has followed the Leafs knows that he's a great regular season player but in the biggest playoff games, all too often he's no better than mediocre. That's what he's shown, you are either blind to this simple fact or maybe you're on Marner's payroll or something.

No, I am not blind, I just have the ability to remember the good he's done in the playoffs as well as the bad.
 

Confucius

There is no try, Just do
Feb 8, 2009
23,005
7,624
Toronto
Running Nylander and Marner on their own lines to see you can carry the offense on their own abilities would be a true test to validate contracts.



Why does Marner always need to be paired up with someone else, to prop him up statistically?

If he wants to be paid like Nylander shouldn't he be capable to do that on his own merits?

Nylander is being moved and tested as a centre because its a more impactful and carries more resposnsibilities, which means he won't be propped up by Matthews/Tavares other centres at ES 5V5.
So JT was propping up William last season?
 

notbias

Registered User
Feb 16, 2017
11,187
9,400
""

Cowan, Holmberg and Robertson given opportunities to succeed. Lorentz given his first look, on a 4th line where nobody on paper should be together.


The McMann - Nylander - Robertson line is intriguing, because I think that'd push Marner or Domi (likely Domi) to Tavares' line, and I actually think that line with a passer could be good.

Also, get Domi and Nylander away from each other.

Nice to get a look at the opening night D too.
 

HockeyVirus

Woll stan.
Nov 15, 2020
18,246
28,069
OurLeafs have a history of playoff failures. For the last 8 playoffs they have on;y once got by the 1st round.

IMHO, our Leafs need to take this pre-season more seriously. They need to establish a winning culture, especially with a new coaching staff, and the fact that they have had a poor record of success in the playoffs the last 8 seasons.

Our very highly paid core needs to start leading this team to higher success. Let's progress towards winning the division at least. Our Leafs needs to show progress in reaching the conference finals too.

I don't give a crap about other teams and their records. Our Leafs need to change their playing standards now, that leads to better playoff success now. IMHO, this starts the moment that they play against regular season opponents in pre-season.

Every year they seem to stall in the 1st round. That needs to change if a Stanley Cup championship is going to become reality before this group of players ages out.

JMHO.

If they went undefeated all pre-season (where half the games is their AHL/ECHL roster and it doesn't matter at all for what the big boys do) AND went undefeated for the first 20 games it would STILL mean absolutely nothing for the playoffs.

All of this is them learning a new system and changing habits. All I care about is they are in a playoff spot in April and rolling at that time. Not now.
 

LEAFANFORLIFE23

Registered User
Jun 17, 2010
47,070
15,692
The McMann - Nylander - Robertson line is intriguing, because I think that'd push Marner or Domi (likely Domi) to Tavares' line, and I actually think that line with a passer could be good.

Also, get Domi and Nylander away from each other.

Nice to get a look at the opening night D too.

Nylander and domi didn't look good together because neither Nylander or Domi are good defensively.

Nylander and Robertson are not going to work together because Nylander is not good defensively and much like Domi neither is Robertson
 
  • Like
Reactions: CincoHolio and 666

notbias

Registered User
Feb 16, 2017
11,187
9,400
Nylander and domi didn't look good together because neither Nylander or Domi are good defensively.

Nylander and Robertson are not going to work together because Nylander is not good defensively and much like Domi neither is Robertson

Domi is by far the worst one there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: arso40

notdoneyet

Registered User
Jun 19, 2006
4,358
1,978
Leafland
This team without Auston Matthews gives a clear vision where this team really stands overall in Cup competitiveness.

Take the 70 goal scorer out of the picture [temporarily] and you get a pretty good vision of depth and team building strategies.

This team is going to go as far as Matthews will carry it, and who are the other impact players or just the followers/passengers.
87 thousand posts and you spew this kind of garbage
Where would oilers be without mcdavid
My god what a revelation
Imagine a team without their top player lol

Look at our history of wins and losses when matthews missed time
 

DragoGrizzly

Registered User
Oct 2, 2019
289
453
87 thousand posts and you spew this kind of garbage
Where would oilers be without mcdavid
My god what a revelation
Imagine a team without their top player lol

Look at our history of wins and losses when matthews missed time
Yup Leafs are 39-19-2 without Matthews in the lineup. We must be pretty deep then! Cup here we come, we’re contenders baby!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rude Dog

DragoGrizzly

Registered User
Oct 2, 2019
289
453
I’m really curious to see how Cowan looks tonight. He’s been playing to not make a mistake, I hope playing with two extremely skilled guys helps unwind him a bit. He just hasnt seemed to be able to find the space he did last preseason even.
 

Fogelhund

Registered User
Sep 15, 2007
22,819
26,460
Seems pretty stupid to not ever play our best defensive prospect in preseason.
Preseason isn't over.

There could be a valid reason he hasn't played... minor injury maybe? What I find weird about it, is there is complete radio silence around it. No media commenting, or asking about him.
 

no2ninja

Registered User
Oct 22, 2023
76
70
Generally preseason games are there for new guys to build chemistry and the team to work out their roster spots, however we have a new coach. New goaltending.

Fan's are excited to see how everything comes together and we all hope to see a bit of what is to come for this season. If there were no changes, same coaching, I wouldn't really care all that much, but I have to admit that I am looking forward to tonight even though it is a preseason game.

Also Pacioretty has me very excited, I love his sound bites, he seems like a stand up guy and a credit to the locker room. I have a feeling he is going to be a huge part of this teams success.
 

jiggy35

Registered User
Jun 26, 2012
638
370
Hope McMann - Nylander - Robertson looks good, really could have 3 dangerous lines if they gel.

Knies - Matthews - Domi
Pacioretty - Tavares - Marner
McMann - Nylander - Robertson
 

Gary Nylund

Registered User
Oct 10, 2013
30,769
24,040
Yes, I'd like to see them together longer before I call them a good duo.

They've been great in their time together though.

Marner led our team in points during his contract year.

If we want to question if Marner was a driver during that year, I question who was driving the line for Matthews last year.

Maybe Domi and Marner were driving the line with Matthews and he was the passenger?

Marner sucked these playoffs, no complaints with that statement, Domi wasn't good either though.

He has shown that, our board just ignores it.

If you added consistently to that, I'd agree.

And all our stars need to.

No, I am not blind, I just have the ability to remember the good he's done in the playoffs as well as the bad.
I don't think I've said anything about a "good duo", just pointing out that Matthews produced just as much with Domi as with Marner so the idea that he needs Marner to produce took a big hit.

LOL at Matthews being the passenger, I'll assume you're not being serious there and just say LOL again.

I don't care much about how many points Marner gets during the regular season, and what he's done lately carries a lot more weight than what he did years ago. This applies to all players as a general rule and Marner sucked in the playoffs not just last season, but also against Florida. And Domi was fine in the playoffs, if he had an 11 million dollar cap hit then I'd say otherwise.

You can lump all our starts together if you like but to my mind, JT and Marner have been much bigger disappointments than Matthews and Nylander. JMHO.
 

Dekes For Days

Registered User
Sep 24, 2018
20,969
15,756
Preseason isn't over. There could be a valid reason he hasn't played... minor injury maybe? What I find weird about it, is there is complete radio silence around it. No media commenting, or asking about him.
Preseason isn't over but not getting into any of the first 3 games is unacceptable if he isn't injured, which he doesn't seem to be.
 

Racer88

Registered User
Sep 29, 2020
11,625
11,642
Domi is a blackhole defensively, and I'd like to see more than half a season of them together.



This is how Marner got his first contract and now everyone cries about it.

Shouldn't you bring up the playoffs and how Domi dropped off significantly when discussing how good he was too?



Pretty much anyone who followed hockey for more than the last few seasons already knows, who is he supposed to be showing?
Marner got his contract because Dubas was an ATM
 

Sypher04

Registered User
Jan 20, 2011
12,595
11,350
Another 'who cares' pre-season game. Our Leafs play like they don't care, while the Habs take the game seriously and try to win the game.

Being win less in pre-season means nothing. It's not important to set a precedence of a winning culture before the games count for real. One just needs to flick on that competitive switch once the games count for real, especially when the playoffs start for real.

Take this game off Auston, there is no reason to get yourself into game shape for the regular season and beyond.

This whole post is beyond ridiculous but I’d like to specifically address the bolded statement.

First of all, we’ve played two games. But despite your trying to mock the concept, preseason results do in fact mean nothing and this has been proven repeatedly over the years
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad