Billy Kvcmu
Registered User
What’s up with CBJ and their allergy toward high end potential
Grub's Canucks & NHL News, Rumours, and & Fantasy GM | Looking for a D-Man to Save Us
- Thread starter Mr. Canucklehead
- Start date
- Status
What’s up with CBJ and their allergy toward high end potential
Billy Kvcmu
Registered User
1+2nd+4th and Hunt for Jiriceck
Still not enough imo, MN’s 1st ain’t worth much this year
Still not enough imo, MN’s 1st ain’t worth much this year
kanucks25
Chris Tanev #1 Fan
Yeah so Hog + D Petey or something was not gonna get it done whatsoever... Unless you think Hog is worth a 1st + 2nd which is obviously not the case
ephmrl
5th overall.
Canucks definitely could've got it done for one of their Abbotsford D + 1st round pick, but then if Jiricek didn't work out they wouldn't have much left to acquire an impact D man. I can see why Allvin would be hesitant to match that Minnesota offer (even though its still relatively poor value for a 6th overall pick from 2 years ago).
Terrible development and asset management by Columbus.
Terrible development and asset management by Columbus.
VanillaCoke
Registered User
- Oct 30, 2013
- 26,391
- 13,075
Classic quantity over quality, I'm surprised no other team beat this offer but also cbj could've done worse I guess
kanucks25
Chris Tanev #1 Fan
The 1st is the biggest piece and worth more on its own than the packages that were being offered here.
So they did go quantity over quality but that quantity was still better than scraps.
Billy Kvcmu
Registered User
ephmrl
5th overall.
Exactly. Canucks would be putting all their eggs in the Jiricek basket by giving up a first + Kudryavtsev/Pettersson which would be quite the gamble for the competitive window of this team. I would rather they spend the assets on more of a known asset such as Marcus Pettersson.
Yeah that 28th pick is huge… I mean our first would have been worth much more than it.
I don't see how or why the Canucks could ever have matched that Wild deal for Jiricek. He's a 'project', pure and simple.
Seems obvious that although the Jackets saw his 'potential', he apparently wasn't good enough to make their everyday lineup. As a 20-year old d-man, he's bound to have his ups and downs in Minny as well.
The Canucks need help now. And hopefully they can acquire it, without being forced to give up yet another first round draft pick.
Seems obvious that although the Jackets saw his 'potential', he apparently wasn't good enough to make their everyday lineup. As a 20-year old d-man, he's bound to have his ups and downs in Minny as well.
The Canucks need help now. And hopefully they can acquire it, without being forced to give up yet another first round draft pick.
kanucks25
Chris Tanev #1 Fan
Hoglander + D Petey is not our 1st.
This was 1st + 2nd + D Petey.
And we'll see where that Minny pick lands.
The original point you replied to was about not offering a bigger piece… that is what people were replying to…
Quinton Byfield
Registered User
- Jul 25, 2021
- 390
- 945
Yeah, and what will Pettersson’s next contract look like?
The idea behind Jiricek was young, and cost controlled. And the return was underwhelming, as expected.
No one thinks Jiricek was going to jump in and play at Pettersson level. But the idea is that in say 2-3 years, he could be a top 4 guy, and we would have his prime years.
Talk about the competitive window all you want, but we can’t afford to waste picks on rentals and older players that we can’t retain.
This is a dealt that makes a massive amount of sense for the Wild. Don’t really have the cap space to get reinforcements that require a 1st, can insulate Jiricek, and the 2nd is two years away.
I don’t like the return for the Blue Jackets but there wasn’t a straight prospect swap available. They’ve mismanaged the relationship for two straight seasons and got stuck in a had spot.
For the Canucks, I have always contended that he doesn’t make sense for the Canucks at what Columbus wanted from them.
I don’t like the return for the Blue Jackets but there wasn’t a straight prospect swap available. They’ve mismanaged the relationship for two straight seasons and got stuck in a had spot.
For the Canucks, I have always contended that he doesn’t make sense for the Canucks at what Columbus wanted from them.
Ah I see the confusion, my brain didn’t brain. Rasmus Andersson.
Jiricek can’t cut it on a lottery team and sounds like a complete twit.
Jacket clearly wanted to cut bait on him and move on. People need to move off the 6OA mindset. Plenty of top 10 picks have not panned out and moved. After 2 full seasons of pro teams have a bit more feel on jiricek.
Big guy who a big shot. Skating/mobility still needs to. Probably average skater at best. Caution moving forward as Evason didn’t feel he was ready for 3rd pairing minutes. And with Gudbranson going down they added help vs give jiricek games or more minutes.
Diversification
Registered User
- Jun 21, 2019
- 3,255
- 4,143
Peen
Rejoicing in a Benning-free world
- Oct 6, 2013
- 31,654
- 28,009
VAN has to be smarter about their allocation of assets.
Yup. VAN paid something similar (arguably less) for Zadorov and Lindholm than what Minnesota just paid for Jiricek alone.
And right now, VAN needs to make two acquisitions of that ilk if they want to properly support this core this year. Can see how they got priced out of a move here.
Seems clear they're trying to spend what they did last year, but avoid doing so for pure rentals unless it's really cheap.
Hoglander + a 3rd + 1st + 2nd + DEP/Mynio/Kudryavtsev for Jiricek and Marcus Pettersson sounds like a lot that doesn't move the needle enough for the team, imo
Yup. VAN paid something similar (arguably less) for Zadorov and Lindholm than what Minnesota just paid for Jiricek alone.
And right now, VAN needs to make two acquisitions of that ilk if they want to properly support this core this year. Can see how they got priced out of a move here.
Seems clear they're trying to spend what they did last year, but avoid doing so for pure rentals unless it's really cheap.
Hoglander + a 3rd + 1st + 2nd + DEP/Mynio/Kudryavtsev for Jiricek and Marcus Pettersson sounds like a lot that doesn't move the needle enough for the team, imo
Yeah, that would be a crazy risky bet for us to make. Willander will be here like march, there is no reason to put all our assets on a guy like Jiricek. If we spend our 1st and 2nd and prospects on 1 player, that player needs to be 100% a top6 forward or a 2nd pairing D.
Side note, sad that the Reddit poster didn’t beat Servalli.
Bourne Endeavor
Registered User
Can't help but laugh a little with this return. Columbus fans were insisting hurt feelings were resolved and Jiriceck would be worth a fortune. Turns out...he was worth exactly what most people thought.
Not a great deal but Waddel really didn't have much leverage here after how horribly the previous management handled things.
Not a great deal but Waddel really didn't have much leverage here after how horribly the previous management handled things.
ephmrl
5th overall.
The limited assets the Canucks have will need to be used to make moves that will help them this season and next. There's too much risk involved in acquiring Jiricek when there's a pretty decent chance he busts and never plays meaningful minutes in the NHL.
Sure, Pettersson's extension might not be ideal, but if he's able to come in and stabilize the defense, that might be a price they have to pay to compete during Hughes' current contract.
- Status
