I knew the 2012 team was special going into the playoffs that year. After the Carter trade, they were clearly one of the best teams in the league, sporting absurd GF and GA differentials over the final two months of that season. Everyone slept on them, though, because their overall record was still pretty average.
The first time I actually thought, “they may win it all” was after sweeping St Louis, who was the darling of the league that year. Everyone thought, “well, Vancouver choked, surely STL will beat them.” And then the Kings whooped their ass. I think STL held a lead for less than 20 minutes combined the entire series. Sheer domination.
And yes, once Chicago was out of the way, I knew they’d beat NYR. I loved that series. The NYR fan base is insufferable, and I loved beating them.