the catch 22 about gino’s skill is he was good enough to not be a total plug, like link gaetz or brian mcgrattan, but not good enough to put that skill to real use playing a real bottom six timely scoring role. but at the same time, his non-skill game wasn’t developed enough to contribute in a fourth line role player way. so he couldn’t be a tim hunter or chris nilan or do what joe kocur did for the rangers and detroit.
a guy like mike peluso, for example, also was good enough to fluke out 15 goals in the perfect situation (in his case getting plum icetime on the expansion sens, ie the worst team of all time). but he also had the ability to credibly grind out 54 playoff games over four years, including a memorable stint on jersey’s cup winning crash line with holik and randy mckay.
but otoh, at the end of game six of the finals, that’s where you regret not dressing gino and hiding him on the fourth line. when graves cheap shotted linden and then messier hit him when he was down, big pat quinn reportedly jumped on sergio momesso’s back to stop him from hopping the boards to take care of business. timmy hunter and antoski were dependable workmanlike fighters but they didn’t scare anyone. gino scared people. partially because he was an elite fighter and partially because he was a loose cannon. he would have hopped those boards and there would have been no stopping him.
i feel like part of why the rangers won that series is this incredible confidence they had and that largely came from knowing they had messier. and while most of that was his abilities as a great player who made things happen on the ice combined with that greatest leader in sports bs, there was also the knowledge that you are an O6 team in the world’s biggest media market and you have the second most made guy in the league as your captain. in any 50/50 or even 60/40 you are going to get the break. so if a team’s heart and soul captain is having a conn smythe performance, you can just take two shots at him behind the play, including while he’s already on the ice, and the refs are going to look the other way.
so enter gino. he would have found a way to correct that. he would have done something crazy and impactful, whether that’s running the shit out of richter the next shift and taking him out of the series, or grabbing and ragdolling messier to within an inch of his life, or hopping the boards and going st louis on the rangers.
and then what does game seven look like? remember that while gino’s suspension would have lasted so long his kids wouldn’t be able to play, we still would be dressing hunter, anton, big mo, diduck, and ready to go if new york had the nerve.