Providence Bruins General Discussion thread ‘24-‘25 II

Does Boston have any better shot at him than the rest of the league with his upcoming UFA status? They never gave him a sniff this year even with the full tank on and him lighting it up in Providence. I have to think he's looking for the best contract and opportunity possible and not sure Boston can offer either.

Boston has a relationship. They have coaching that has it seemed progressed his career. And they will have the first chance to sign him. So they have a better shot than other teams.

I don't think there will be a substantial difference in contracts offered to him whether in Boston or elsewhere . Maybe he gets an extra year somewhere or an extra 100K .

I would suspect that whether it is in Boston or somewhere else he will have to fight for a job in training camp
 
Boston has a relationship. They have coaching that has it seemed progressed his career. And they will have the first chance to sign him. So they have a better shot than other teams.

I don't think there will be a substantial difference in contracts offered to him whether in Boston or elsewhere . Maybe he gets an extra year somewhere or an extra 100K .

I would suspect that whether it is in Boston or somewhere else he will have to fight for a job in training camp
Yeah I guess I just don't know what that relationship is. He's been great for Providence for the last two years and never got a taste of the NHL in this org.
 
Remember Khokhlachev and Cehlarik having 20 goal seasons for Providence yet never sticking with the Bruins (or any other NHL teams).

And defenseman Jakub Zboril was a first-round pick who couldn't make the jump .

Maybe the gap is that big from the AHL to the NHL.
I know a guy who played in the AHL for years and went to one of the top level euro leagues after that. Was point per game+ in AHL and put up a 100 point season as well, and only got a handful of nhl games. He’s told me that the difference in the speed of the passing and the speed of everybody else’s hands was just too much. He’s a super high hockey iq guy too, probably his best attribute, his hands just wouldn’t let his game translate.
 
for all the talk about the B`s not developing prospects properly, I can`t think of any true prospects that weren`t given a chance here that have flourished elsewhere?

There have been players who the B`s drafted and traded (Lindgren as example) who have had nice careers but I think the issue is the B`s simply missing on picks, not necessarily developing them improperly. I highly doubt Merk, if he were to move on somewhere else will somehow become a significant contributor to a NHL team
 
for all the talk about the B`s not developing prospects properly, I can`t think of any true prospects that weren`t given a chance here that have flourished elsewhere?

There have been players who the B`s drafted and traded (Lindgren as example) who have had nice careers but I think the issue is the B`s simply missing on picks, not necessarily developing them improperly. I highly doubt Merk, if he were to move on somewhere else will somehow become a significant contributor to a NHL team
I guess you could say Vatrano or Donato but they both didn't show much more than an average at best NHL game until their late 20's. You have to give credit where its due, they both grinded to get where they're at.

Your point stands tho
 
I guess you could say Vatrano or Donato but they both didn't show much more than an average at best NHL game until their late 20's. You have to give credit where its due, they both grinded to get where they're at.

Your point stands tho
yep, again, I don`t think it`s a developing issue, I think it`s a talent issue, B`s miscalculating a players potential and missing on picks but the B`s also have a pretty solid history of drafting, developing players in rounds 2 and onward who go onto pretty solid roles with the big club

Donato, classic one, has now played on what? 5 teams, offensively broke out this year and he`ll get paid by a fool of a GM and get the Matt Beleskey result when he returns to minimal offensive contributions and the B`s snagged Coyle for him which was a massive win for the B`s

I liked Vatrano in bits, has carved out a nice little career for himself , B`s used the 3rd rounder for Lauko I believe so they didn`t really win that deal and if I recall, he was brutal the first quarter of that year and Debrusk and Heinen stepped in and took a job from him
 
for all the talk about the B`s not developing prospects properly, I can`t think of any true prospects that weren`t given a chance here that have flourished elsewhere?

There have been players who the B`s drafted and traded (Lindgren as example) who have had nice careers but I think the issue is the B`s simply missing on picks, not necessarily developing them improperly. I highly doubt Merk, if he were to move on somewhere else will somehow become a significant contributor to a NHL team
Yep, I think you nailed it. Be careful though there's probably still people around here who think Jared Knight and Zach Senyshyn would've been stars if it weren't for how Boston/Providence developed them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ODAAT and Jim
Yep, I think you nailed it. Be careful though there's probably still people around here who think Jared Knight and Zach Senyshyn would've been stars if it weren't for how Boston/Providence developed them.
Jared Knight's issues were medical. Had he not had complications with injuries and his diabetes, he was gonna be great. It's unfortunate.
 
No, he wasn't going to be great. He simply wasn't an NHL level player.
I'm no Knight fanboy like some people were.

But declaring a guy who had health issues like diabetes as incapable of being an NHL player is silly.

No one has a clue how much that could of effected him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mione134
No, he wasn't going to be great. He simply wasn't an NHL level player.
Do you even remember his health struggles? Especially his diabetes? Do you remember is injuries? In fact, did you even watch in him or know of the player at all?

His diabetes derailled his career and it's a shame he could never recover because of it. His draft stock slipped because he found out he had diabetes in junior, which explained his health issues.

Ankle. Hamstring injuries. Etc


Nobody will know what kind of a player he would of been without the diabetes and injuries. And it's disingenuous to say otherwise.
 
Last edited:
I'm no Knight fanboy like some people were.

But declaring a guy who had health issues like diabetes as incapable of being an NHL player is silly.

No one has a clue how much that could of effected him.
Maybe but others have overcome injuries and diabetes. I watched him play live many times when he was in the OHL and thought he'd become a good 3rd liner. If he really had NHL star talent then he would've made the league eventually despite the setbacks.
 
Do you even remember his health struggles? Especially his diabetes? Do you remember is injuries? In fact, did you even watch in him or know of the player at all?

His diabetes derailled his career and it's a shame he could never recover because of it. His draft stock slipped because he found out he had diabetes in junior, which explained his health issues. He also had mono that kept him out of Canada's world juniors camp.

Ankle. Hamstring injuries. Etc


Nobody will know what kind of a player he would of been without the diabetes and injuries. And it's disingenuous to say otherwise.
I watched him play live many times in the OHL and I'm guessing you didn't. It was obvious to anyone who wasn't a homer that he didn't have top 6 offensive talent. Saying he didn't have NHL level talent was a bit harsh but he was never going to be a star player.
 
Maybe but others have overcome injuries and diabetes. I watched him play live many times when he was in the OHL and thought he'd become a good 3rd liner. If he really had NHL star talent then he would've made the league eventually despite the setbacks.
I'm not even talking about the player specifically, and I certainly think most injuries are able to be overcome, but just seems... shortsighted to rule out a guy making it when he was derailed by an illness.

Also you said in your own post he looked like a 3rd liner, your other post said he wasn't an nhl player. You think his health issues might have been the reason that happened?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mione134
Do you even remember his health struggles? Especially his diabetes? Do you remember is injuries? In fact, did you even watch in him or know of the player at all?

His diabetes derailled his career and it's a shame he could never recover because of it. His draft stock slipped because he found out he had diabetes in junior, which explained his health issues. He also had mono that kept him out of Canada's world juniors camp.

Ankle. Hamstring injuries. Etc


Nobody will know what kind of a player he would of been without the diabetes and injuries. And it's disingenuous to say otherwise.

Wasn't Knight a US player?
 
Maybe but others have overcome injuries and diabetes. I watched him play live many times when he was in the OHL and thought he'd become a good 3rd liner. If he really had NHL star talent then he would've made the league eventually despite the setbacks.
I watched enough of him to know that his health issues and injuries derailed his career. He would of made a fine 3rd liner *had* these things not derailled his career. We'll never know. And not every player with health issues can come back from it.


@DKH Wanna chime in here on Jared Knight.
 
I watched enough of him to know that his health issues and injuries derailed his career. He would of made a fine 3rd liner *had* these things not derailled his career. We'll never know. And not every player with health issues can come back from it.


@DKH Wanna chime in here on Jared Knight.
He had diabetes and started wearing a pump during games

Injuries didn’t heal well… lotta stuff

But he is smart went to medical school etc did well, wife a lawyer etc.,,

Miss the days of Spooner, Krug, and Knight, 2 dogs and chaos all in an apartment

Knight was normal as they come, Spooner was like 90 % of my HS friends - he would have crushed it in late 70’s early 80’s….Krug was the funniest nicest guy. Bummed me out they didn’t keep him

2019 Cup would have solidified Torey Krug here
 
I guess you could say Vatrano or Donato but they both didn't show much more than an average at best NHL game until their late 20's. You have to give credit where its due, they both grinded to get where they're at.

Your point stands tho
Vatrano but I'd put an asterisk on Donato because you could argue we maximized his value at that time. So we didn't give up on him anymore then we gave up on Dougie Hamilton.
 
I'm no Knight fanboy like some people were.

But declaring a guy who had health issues like diabetes as incapable of being an NHL player is silly.

No one has a clue how much that could of effected him.
I'd say it was highly unlikely he was going to be an NHL player. People got excited about a draft pick that was ranked in the 100’s at the time of his draft after an article about the diabetes and big back to back weekends in the ohl after getting on medication. I never bought the hype.

What could have been, sure who knows but most likely he just wasn't as good as the guys who passed him like Spooner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DaaaaB's
I'm not even talking about the player specifically, and I certainly think most injuries are able to be overcome, but just seems... shortsighted to rule out a guy making it when he was derailed by an illness.

Also you said in your own post he looked like a 3rd liner, your other post said he wasn't an nhl player. You think his health issues might have been the reason that happened?
I also said in my next post that saying that was a bit harsh. However, there's been many players who I thought would become good 3rd liners who didn't make it so I wouldn't put too much stock into that. He was just barely over a ppg in his best OHL season, that's not going to translate to being great in the NHL. He just didn't have the offensive talent.
 
I watched enough of him to know that his health issues and injuries derailed his career. He would of made a fine 3rd liner *had* these things not derailled his career. We'll never know. And not every player with health issues can come back from it.


@DKH Wanna chime in here on Jared Knight.
He might've become a fine 3rd liner as he had a solid two way game. His lack of offence might've also made him a 4th liner or AHL player. I really don't care now and no one chiming in will change my mind.
 
Any idea what Providence lineup will be
Gotta think Locmelis plays even with guys sent down
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad