He passes the eye test? Hardly. He still makes so many dumb plays because he doesn't think ahead. So many opposition chances off him firing wide.
Every defenseman on this team has scored before him, including the one with 5 games.
It's good that Marty and Kent like him, because no one is trading for him.
Agree to disagree. Anderson makes a lot of poor decisions but it's no coincidence that Anderson ends up with the puck five times a shift. Even on that great pass to Newhook he picked up the puck and lost the puck in our end, took it away, gave it away, took it away again to start the rush and got to the front of the net all in about 15 seconds. Nick Suzuki for example only touched the puck once that entire shift.
Andy's relentless out there. It's why he leads the league in penalties drawn. Anderson also has a positive giveaway takeaway ratio and is second on the team in takeaways and near the bottom of the team for giveaways. Meanwhile Gally leads the forwards in negative penalty differential. Xhekaj leads the entire league. These are the warriors and Anderson is useless according to fans.
Yeah despite these good things Andy is hella overpaid, but he's not useless and actively hurting the team the way Gally or Pearson do. Anderson would make 32 teams in the leagues rosters, even in a fourth line role. Gally, Pearson, rhp, Pezz, etc are guys that are in the league because there aren't 32 teams worth of NHL players in the world.