flyerslducks
Registered User
- Feb 15, 2017
- 12,746
- 13,603
Proposal: Gab Vilardi for Carter Hart
- Thread starter De Montreal
- Start date
- Status
1865
Alpha Couturier
I don’t want them to. But if a single person in their scouting staff thinks it’s a bad idea to trade Vilardi for him then they likely need to lose their job.
AddyTheWrath
Registered User
Frolov 6'3
Unregistered User
Career high of 13 points and 1 point this season ? Nice way to come up with stats in a ridiculous way and ignoring all kind of aspects.
He would have had 16 goals 35 points in a full season last year. You do know there was a shortened season ? All that after being out FOR MONTHS. Yes meanwhile he is a 22 year old yes. That happens if you miss 1,5 year of hockey.
He should be playing right now too. His AHL stats speak volumes, so was his performance last season. He should not be traded for Hart.
Vilardi is a full time NHL player. Your response is another low for HF, not mine.
Last edited:
Overrateprospects
Registered User
- Dec 23, 2021
- 244
- 52
Rangers should acquire him for a 4th rounder if that’s the case
OneSniffTwoSniff
Registered User
- Jan 18, 2022
- 577
- 492
Holy Slapshot
Registered User
I'm pretty sure his dad wouldn't be able to promote him better. Agree he's promising player by the way, but trade him for Hart?! Come on...
1865
Alpha Couturier
13 was a small-screen typo. All due respect to Villardi (who i'd be into acquiring in a different deal) but nothing screams star about him and his PPG is down year on year. He'll probably be a perfectly good player and I get you're protective of him but you're comparing different class of player here. Carter Hart is well on track to becoming one of the best goalies in the world whereas Vilardi is a full time NHL player.
Frolov 6'3
Unregistered User
I dont want to talk about Hart actually but what is Hart exactly showing he is well on track to becoming one of the best goalies in the world ?
You get I am protective about Vilardi by showing some facts. Yet you come up with hyperbole about Hart. You are the one who is protective about Hart, not me about Vilardi.
I get that you like Vilardi and we like Hart. But in the grand scheme of things, Vilardi for Hart (straight up) massively favors the Kings.
Frolov 6'3
Unregistered User
The most annoying stuff is the false information you read about Gabe throughout this topic whether you like player A or B.
Give it some time. We could speak about this within 2 years.
Both are still young. Not even in their prime yet.
We get the same stuff around Hart as well. He struggled last year, the Flyers are awful this year, so Hart must be the problem/part of the problem. Which couldn't be further from the truth.
KirkAlbuquerque
#WeNeverGetAGoodCoach
Nothing. Really this isn't the time for LA to acquire a goalie.
LA should be looking at Provorov. Add Vilardi in a package for Provorov if he's made available.
OrangeAndBlackMetal
Dark Wizard of the Black Cascade
Raccoon Jesus
Draft em but don't play em
Nothing, but Petersen is 27, Quick is 36, and there's no real heir apparent in the system. Some guys with great potential like Parik, Ingham, Hrenak but nothing certain to align with the age of their blue chippers. Kings reportedly were trading up for Wallsteadt, so they know what time it is. I can see the thought process in chasing a young guy, minus the richard-measuring contest this thread turned into.
go4hockey
Registered User
Rorschach
Who the f*** is Trevor Moore?
A lot of pointless arguing in this thread due to the OP not addressing either team's needs. LA is not looking for a Carter Hart-type of goalie. We just signed Cal Petersen and Quick has had a resurgence of late. Some in LA would say we need a LHD, some would say we need a true game-breaking scoring winger...I would say, both would be nice. Unless there's something I don't know about Carter Hart, he's not either.
And Philly is not looking for an under-achieving young forward who, although still has good potential, isn't a proven NHL player yet.
No need to insult the other team's asset to simply say, the offer is not what we're looking for.
And Philly is not looking for an under-achieving young forward who, although still has good potential, isn't a proven NHL player yet.
No need to insult the other team's asset to simply say, the offer is not what we're looking for.
ponder719
The same New Era as before
From the sound of things, if the Kings were going after a goalie from the Flyers, they'd probably be more interested in someone further away, like Ustimenko or Ersson, who could step in as Petersen's backup if/when Quick decides to retire, and then potentially grow into a starter. We might have a more interesting and less contentious thread if we were talking about that. The Flyers, meanwhile, have our wagon hitched to Hart, and would only be justified in moving him for a much bigger name than we normally see as a return for a goalie.
Gabe Vilardi isn’t really an NHL player. He doesn’t have much value at all. He’s at the stalled prospect point of his career journey. Insane to think he’d fetch a 1G. Even a struggling g young one. He himself is very much a struggling young player that isn’t so young anymore.
Yog S'loth
Registered User
Carter Hart, though on a bad team, is a #1 goalie in the NHL.
Gabe Vilardi is a 22-year-old minor-leaguer.
Gabe Vilardi is a 22-year-old minor-leaguer.
Doubt anyone is calling on a minor league guy. Vilardi… maybe worth a 3rd or 4th right now.
probably not an NHL caliber player/prospect. Kings have a good farm system. This guy isn’t really a part of that.
- Status
