Proposal: Gab Vilardi for Carter Hart

[izzy]

As an Ontario Reign season ticket holder I think I have a better grasp of his value than you.

glad he’s doing so well in the ahl lol

 

[Crown Royal]

glad he’s doing so well in the ahl lol

Vilardi scored again today. Maybe Carter Hart could benefit from some AHL time too.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Vilardi scored again today. Maybe Carter Hart could benefit from some AHL time too.

This is such an ignorant and clearly salty take

 

[izzy]

Vilardi scored again today. Maybe Carter Hart could benefit from some AHL time too.

thats awesome, if he keeps it up maybe he will catch the legendary martin frk in points!

 

[Crown Royal]

thats awesome, if he keeps it up maybe he will catch the legendary martin frk in points!

That slap shot of his is pretty “legendary”. He comes up to the NHL every now and then to terrorize opposing goalies with it. We love Marty.

 

[izzy]

That slap shot of his is pretty “legendary”. He comes up to the NHL every now and then to terrorize opposing goalies with it. We love Marty.

i need to stop visiting this site

 

[Lil Sebastian Cossa]

Would not trade Vilardi for Hart.

Wouldn’t trade Vilardi at all.

You wouldn't get Hart for Vilardi. Like not even close.

 

[Lil Sebastian Cossa]

Maybe it's time for Carter Hart to get out of Philadelpia. If the Flyers are serious about moving away from Giroux and the core, Vilardi is a good replacement for the future. Kings are stacked up front with Byfield, Fagemo, Turcotte, Kupari and could afford to lose Vilardi to get a potential #1 goalie.

Love this. LA has like four Cs we like over Vilardi. So, he should definitely be worth a #1G.

 

[BrindamoursNose]

Old man Quick has better numbers.

That doesn't refute what I said.

 

[Djp]

Maybe it's time for Carter Hart to get out of Philadelpia. If the Flyers are serious about moving away from Giroux and the core, Vilardi is a good replacement for the future. Kings are stacked up front with Byfield, Fagemo, Turcotte, Kupari and could afford to lose Vilardi to get a potential #1 goalie.

vallardi doesn’t have that value
And
Hart isn’t old enough to be moved as part of a rebuild

 

[Docgonzo]

Sorry, you wouldn’t trade a 22 year old with 1 point this season and a career high of… 13 points for Carter Hart?! This is a new and impressive low for HF.

Flyers won’t trade Hart but first Vilardi has 23 career high points not 13. And why would the Kings trade for a goalie whose played 4 seasons in the nhl and has a career save percentage of .907? Knocking down players can go both ways.

 

[Hobnobs]

Kings fans overvaluing of prospects reaches critical mass... Not saying Kings need Hart but if they did, Hart has more value on the market than Vilardi.

 

[KingsHockey24]

Sure.

 

[Kurrilino]

We like it or not, Petersen is our future goalie.
He was given a 5 mil contract over several years.

Only the future will show if that what a correct decision or not.
Until his contract is up, he will be the #1 goalie after Quick

 

[izzy]

Flyers won’t trade Hart but first Vilardi has 23 career points not 13. And why would the Kings trade for a goalie whose played 4 seasons in the nhl and has a career save percentage of .907? Knocking down players can go both ways.

the post u quoted says career high, not total

 

[Kurrilino]

Carter Hart will be a #1 goalie for a long time in the NHL.

Statistically speaking, every goalie that's walked his specific path to the NHL has gone on to become a career starter at-worse, except for Jim Carrey.

@Appleyard had the stats on this (which are fascinating) and are pretty hard to refute

And shouldn't teams keep their #1 goalie?
Just out of interest

 

[kings11]

Kings fans overvaluing of prospects reaches critical mass... Not saying Kings need Hart but if they did, Hart has more value on the market than Vilardi.

I agree, not sure who came up with that trade but Hart would cost more.. the other factor is that the Kings aren’t moving Vilardi as they are smitten with him and with the team willing they’re letting him grow and learn in the A.. which is something he really hasn’t done with all the time he’s missed.. but it’s nice that he’s a ppg player

 

[PDX Flyer]

Hart has one of the highest save percentages of high danger zone shots, if not the highest. He has been terrific. It is the dumpster fire in front of him that he is bailing out.

yeah he wasn’t good last year but that lands on AV being a total mind f*** to him in the open media.

putting his numbers up on a team with a 13 game losing streak, the second 10 game of the season, with Yandle, Risto etc.... let alone that bottom six.....

Hart isn’t the problem and I hope he goes get moved out. Been a huge fan since his Everett days and he doesn’t deserve the mess the Flyers are

 

[Docgonzo]

the post u quoted says career high, not total

And 23 is his career high, I left out high after career. He scored 23 in 53 last season.

 

[BrindamoursNose]

And shouldn't teams keep their #1 goalie?
Just out of interest

Of course. Trading Carter Hart is beyond dumb for the Flyers.

 

[TomKosto]

Rather use Vilardi as part of a deal to get Sanheim or Provorov

Good luck with that

 

[Raccoon Jesus]

huh, hes 23, most goalies are still waiting to get their shot at the nhl at this point

meanwhile vilardi is a 22 yo forward who can’t crack the roster of a middle of the league (likely easily in the bottom half when the teams behind them catch them in GP) in scoring team and has injury concerns

To be fair that's because LA's roster management is atrocious and they're playing waiver games, not because Vilardi shouldn't be there.

Doesn't mean he's worth Hart but also doesn't mean he's as trash which is what's going on in this used-car-sale thread

 

[Dumpster Flyers]

I haven't seen Vilardi play this season. Is he still **** skater?

 

[Sol]

Would not trade Vilardi for Hart.

Wouldn’t trade Vilardi at all.

Vilardi is expendable

 

[TeddyBare]

As an Ontario Reign season ticket holder I think I have a better grasp of his value than you.

congrats on thinking a guy who has played at high level in the NHL is worth less than a slow skating center in the final year of waiver exemption that has proven nothing on the NHL.