Toggle sidebar

Future "What if...?": Crosby's Final Years

Empoleon8771

Empoleon8771

Registered User
Aug 25, 2015
85,458
85,970
Redmond, WA
coooldude said:
Love these main boards shit fights. 90% of posters agree (on this thread: "he's probably not leaving Pittsburgh, but if he does, it's probably to Colorado") ... And then 10% of posters, haters and lovers of the topical player and then usually some Habs fans sprinkled in, get into wild back and forths that devolve into flaming.

We're only missing some Russians to bring up Ovie, or God forbid Michkov, and dial the chaos up another level.
Click to expand...

It's even more bizarre in this case because the initial claim was so tame that it didn't even remotely deserve that level of response. The idea is equating Crosby helping McDavid win to what Gretzky did to help Lemieux while they played together in the Canada cup, which isn't a ridiculous claim and is in no way taking away from McDavid's legacy.

I'm not super well versed on it because it was before my time, but from the late 1980s Penguins games that I've seen on Youtube, the broadcasters mentioned more than once how Gretzky helped Lemieux grow into a leadership role and be more than just a points farmer on a bad team. I don't think McDavid needs that kind of help like Lemieux allegedly needed back then, but "veteran helping the talented younger guy develop into a winner" is something the NHL saw with two of its best players ever with Lemieux and Gretzky.
 

Soundwave

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
73,844
29,904
I think Crosby, MacKinnon, McDavid (and Marner) are all together right now actually.

I knew McDavid was in Vail, Colorado, but I couldn't figure out why, most of the Oilers including Draisaitl are already back in Edmonton. I was thinking maybe an extended honeymoon thing as Vail is a popular destination town, but now that Freidman I think has said Crosby/MacK/Marner are in Vail, it makes sense that McDavid is there too, lol.

Team Canada prep most likely.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sanscosm
The Panther

The Panther

Registered User
Mar 25, 2014
20,045
17,015
Tokyo, Japan
Sign with Edmonton, Sid. Can you imagine this top nine?:

Hyman - McDavid - Draisaitl
Arvidsson - Crosby - Skinner
Kane - Henrique - Nugent-Hopkins

Keep the 4th-line on the bench and we good.
 
im gangster

im gangster

SMD
Sponsor
May 3, 2021
8,893
8,924
Sid to Vancouver, please. Rutherford has the juice to make something like that happen. He would be a godsend to the powerplay and oh yeah, top of the C depth chart on a team with Pettersson and J.T. Miller. 🤤
 
KingsFan7824

KingsFan7824

Registered User
Dec 4, 2003
19,526
7,599
Visit site
Soundwave said:
If you're still playing at a high level, why limit yourself based on age.

We're seeing in other sports the rise of top end athletes playing well into their mid/late 30s and even 40s. LeBron James is turning 40 this season. Steph Curry is only like 7 months younger than Crosby. Tom Brady was competing for Superbowls at age 40/41 also. A sport that used to be like "you turn 30 and you're finished" like tennis now has Djokovic at age 37 still being a top player.

Look there's a perfectly reasonable argument for staying put for Sid, but if it's a 100% slam dunk, I think he would've signed by now. What's the hold up? I don't think never playing in the playoffs again while he's still a high level player is something he'd be thrilled with.
Click to expand...

I'm saying Crosby has no limit. He doesn't gain or lose anything no matter where, or if, he plays after this year. There's no goal record he's going to get. There's no points record to get. He's got the Cups, and two back to back. He's already a top 50, 20, 10, whatever player ever. There are no unanswered questions. Nothing he does from now on will change anything. He's free to do as he wants.

The only thing that would really be overly impressive is if he was the leader of this aging Pens team with no depth winning another Cup.
 
Voodoo Child

Voodoo Child

Registered User
Jun 16, 2009
6,476
2,587
My hot take is he probably retires a Pen, but maybe he ends up going to Colorado, his first ballot has been stamped for a decade and he can do what he wants.
 
Luigi Lemieux

Luigi Lemieux

Registered User
Sep 26, 2003
22,009
10,362
KingsFan7824 said:
I'm saying Crosby has no limit. He doesn't gain or lose anything no matter where, or if, he plays after this year. There's no goal record he's going to get. There's no points record to get. He's got the Cups, and two back to back. He's already a top 50, 20, 10, whatever player ever. There are no unanswered questions. Nothing he does from now on will change anything. He's free to do as he wants.

The only thing that would really be overly impressive is if he was the leader of this aging Pens team with no depth winning another Cup.
Click to expand...
How I feel as well. His place in history is set, it doesn't really matter in that sense if he wins 3 or 4 cups. It's about what he wants to do for his final years. He's earned that, so I'm ok if he wants to stay in pittsburgh, and ok if he wants to go and try for more cups.
 
Pip

Pip

Registered User
Feb 2, 2012
69,387
8,896
Granduland
waitin425 said:
if he went to Montreal next year, what makes you think it wouldn't be for a cup.

Slaf - Suzuki - Caufield
Laine - Crosby - Demidov
Newhook - Dach - Roy
Anderson - Kapanen/Beck - Gally

feel free to try and flame that lineup....but that would be at or near the top of the league.
Click to expand...
Because the goal would be to go to a team already at the top and adding Crosby would put them over the top, not a team that needs him to be considered near the top of the league
 
  • Like
Reactions: coooldude
Crow

Crow

Registered User
May 19, 2014
4,461
3,306
Pierce Hawthorne said:
Anybody who thinks he'd go anywhere but Colorado is just being silly.


Anybody that thinks he'd even leave Pittsburgh in the first place are being like 99% silly.
Click to expand...
Only hesitation I have in saying that is it is not the same group or family who drafted him that now owns anything close to a majority of the pens. Maybe he doesn’t feel much loyalty toward the new group.
 
SEALBound

SEALBound

Fancy Gina Carano
Sponsor
Jun 13, 2010
42,615
21,408
Not resigning this year leaves open the possibility of heading out at the TDL to a cup contender. Then resigns in Pittsburgh for the remainder of the year.

I think that's Colorado pretty easily. That said, I gotta think that if Sid is willing to go to another team, he might just drag that team across the finish line come hell or high water. I don't think he's going to taint the "one team" aspect of his legacy for a maybe. So a team is really going to have to go for it. Doubt Sid will do it if his linemates are 3rd line caliber guys.
 

Toby91ca

Registered User
Oct 17, 2022
2,463
1,823
I don't see him going anywhere else, but who knows. This isn't a Ray Bourque scenario....he already has the cups. The only two big items I'd think of are 1) perhaps he is simply dead set against playing out his career on a team that isn't going anywhere....you can't imagine that team improving over the next 3-4 years or 2) perhaps he wants to help the team before he leaves....a trade would bring in big pieces to rebuild vs. nothing if he plays out to retirement....you don't really see that happen much though.
 

GOilers88

#FreeMoustacheRides
Dec 24, 2016
15,100
22,549
I hope he stays in Pittsburgh. He has no reason to chase a cup.

He's won everything the sport can offer. He's made more money than he could spend in a lifetime. Nothing could better cement his career than by spending the entirety of it with one team.
 
varsaku

varsaku

Registered User
Feb 14, 2014
2,666
903
United States
Bouboumaster said:
50% Colorado
50% Montréal

IMO

No other teams would be considered

Colorado because of Mack and the chance to get one more Cup

Montréal because it was his team growing up, it's the "local team" for him and he played his junior in Québec
Plus, Montréal is a young team on verge to finish their rebuild
Click to expand...
We may be nearing the end of the rebuild but we are no where close to contending for the Cup. If he is leaving Pittsburgh it is for another cup otherwise he will be retiring there.
We unfortunately still lack that star player to really push the team to the next level that every cup winning team has.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coooldude and Golden_Jet
Neutrinos

Neutrinos

Registered User
Sep 23, 2016
8,946
3,843
He didn't grow up dreaming of playing with Nathan MacKinnon...

If he goes anywhere, I think it'll be Montreal
 
  • Like
Reactions: viceroy
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom
X