Injury Report: Freddie Andersen to be out until early February or March following knee surgery

[Stickpucker]

Except if it is a mental issue, that isn't a question of "compete." That's a serious medical condition that he likely has little control over. So you constantly going after him for "the Freddie flu" is in poor taste, to say the least.

My question would be, if it is a mental problem, why has he not reached out to the NHLPA about it (that we're aware of)?

Maybe because we never pushed the issue and gave him the time he needed?

 

[A Star is Burns]

I do think we need to explore all options and probably consider finding another good goalie for insurance. But many thought Freddie wouldn't make it back last season and he did. I imagine he will this season as well and it makes things difficult to juggle.

 

[Joe McGrath]

Am I crazy or is 8-12 weeks not at all late March or early April as the thread title suggests?

Edit: Its a Freddie joke, I get it. Carry on.

 

[Joe McGrath]

I mean, day to day ended up being effectively a season ending injury if the current timeline to recover from surgery is correct

If the current timeline is to be believed he will be back with over 30% of the regular season left.

That’s is almost as far off from effectively season ending as the original diagnosis. Whether you buy the new timeline is a different discussion all together.

 

[Svechhammer]

If the current timeline is to be believed he will be back with over 30% of the regular season left.

That’s is almost as far off from effectively season ending as the original diagnosis. Whether you buy the new timeline is a different discussion all together.

Hmmm now that I am checking again that should be early Feb or March, I think my math didn't math well

 

[Joe McGrath]

Hmmm now that I am checking again that should be early Feb or March, I think my math didn't math well

12 weeks is right at the Four Nations face-off break. In theory he could rehab in Chicago during that break at the tail end of the timeline. Now obviously its Freddie so we may never see him again anyway.

 

[Ole Gil]

12 weeks is right at the Four Nations face-off break. In theory he could rehab in Chicago during that break at the tail end of the timeline. Now obviously its Freddie so we may never see him again anyway.

Plenty of time to squeeze in one more week-to-week injury.

 

[Borsig]

even if he makes it back I dont want him in the playoffs unless hes backing up.

I'm done with his failures.

 

[chaz4hockey]

even if he makes it back I dont want him in the playoffs unless hes backing up.

I'm done with his failures.

I understand your POV and also am not a current fan of Freddie.

To be fair, he did play superbly in the playoffs/series against Cats 2 years ago. His absence due to blood clots LY perhaps didn’t give him enough time to be totally ready (mentally and physically) too.

Hopefully this knee surgery fixed whatever has caused him to have issues. Otherwise, sign me up for a trade for a younger/high quality goalie versus getting an oft injured retread.

 

[Finlandia WOAT]

Rod was vocal about not liking a platoon of goalies, and that led to the team signing Andersen and him playing 52 games his first year here. Him breaking down, you have to think at least partially because of that season, has to have the front office and especially Rod reconsidering, no? You'd hope.

For context, Andersen started 51 games his first season year, and the next 2 and a half he started 53.

 

[chaz4hockey]

A view on Gibson:

 

[User13452]

A view on Gibson:

View attachment 934162

One thing I’d say about that is the difference between the way Edmonton defends and Carolina does I think the canes can make a lot of goalies look good the way they tend to not give up so many high danger chances and shots against. I think Gibson would do quite well in Carolina imo you never know what a fresh start on a contending team can do for a guy who’s been on a basement dweller team for years

 

[Joe McGrath]

One thing I’d say about that is the difference between the way Edmonton defends and Carolina does I think the canes can make a lot of goalies look good the way they tend to not give up so many high danger chances and shots against. I think Gibson would do quite well in Carolina imo you never know what a fresh start on a contending team can do for a guy who’s been on a basement dweller team for years

Based on what every goalie who leaves looks like post Canes, I think they can get any of the top 90 goalies in the world and make him look like a capable NHL goalie.