Toggle sidebar

GDT: Four Nations Thread

Who wins?

  • Total voters
    28
  • Poll closed .
JTG said:
That was probably the best hockey game I have ever seen. The World Cup of Hockey has to come back stronger than ever. Fans and players deserve this. What an absolute treat. I felt like a kid. Saturday just because SO much more fun for me.
Click to expand...
I have always felt that the effort/dedication and availability of top players totally outweighs format concerns.
They're all clearly trying their best, and it's not very different from an Olympics semi-finals, with 4 teams left.
Yeah it sucks that Russia is not there, but they likely wouldn't have made the final 4 anyway. They don't defend well enough.

So I'll gladly accept this tournament, regardless of the motives behind it. I care a lot more about results.
 
Randy Butternubs said:
Hoping Sid is whispering in all the UFA ears.
Click to expand...
"wherever you sign, make sure they have 8.7 free in cap space, if you catch my drift *wink wink*"


So I've been on HF since 2009. A long time, but not quite long enough to answer this question: Why does HF, outside of Pens fans and a few neutrals, have such a hate-on for Sid. I'm not terminally online, so I assumed the hf attitude was the prevailing online attitude towards Sid. Nope, literally anywhere else and it's people of every fan base practically worshiping the guy, calling him a top-5 player of all time (which, obviously, he is), and generally gushing about him.

So why is it whenever I read stuff here it's calling him overrated and talking about his frosted tips? Just crazy. This place (hf in general, not the Pens board) has shitty vibes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: canadianguy77
IcedCapp said:
"wherever you sign, make sure they have 8.7 free in cap space, if you catch my drift *wink wink*"


So I've been on HF since 2009. A long time, but not quite long enough to answer this question: Why does HF, outside of Pens fans and a few neutrals, have such a hate-on for Sid. I'm not terminally online, so I assumed the hf attitude was the prevailing online attitude towards Sid. Nope, literally anywhere else and it's people of every fan base practically worshiping the guy, calling him a top-5 player of all time (which, obviously, he is), and generally gushing about him.

So why is it whenever I read stuff here it's calling him overrated and talking about his frosted tips? Just crazy. This place (hf in general, not the Pens board) has shitty vibes.
Click to expand...

People hate success. Especially here of all places.
 
  • Like
Reactions: canadianguy77
Been here since 05’ and from what I remember it was mainly about Sid v. OV and in his early years, Sid would snap his head back pretty ridiculously when high sticked and “whine” while OV steam rolled people and shot the puck a billion times.

So it was mainly Washington/philly fans invading most threads and there were tons of Sid v. OV ones created every day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: End of Line, Randy Butternubs and canadianguy77
IcedCapp said:
"wherever you sign, make sure they have 8.7 free in cap space, if you catch my drift *wink wink*"


So I've been on HF since 2009. A long time, but not quite long enough to answer this question: Why does HF, outside of Pens fans and a few neutrals, have such a hate-on for Sid. I'm not terminally online, so I assumed the hf attitude was the prevailing online attitude towards Sid. Nope, literally anywhere else and it's people of every fan base practically worshiping the guy, calling him a top-5 player of all time (which, obviously, he is), and generally gushing about him.

So why is it whenever I read stuff here it's calling him overrated and talking about his frosted tips? Just crazy. This place (hf in general, not the Pens board) has shitty vibes.
Click to expand...
Go to any social media post or Reddit thread and you'll see similar types of terminally online people who are emotionally over-invested in a variety of topics. On a forum like this, Crosby - being the face of the NHL for so long - is a lightning rod for that type of negative energy.
 
International teams games often don't live up to the hype generated by the star-studded rosters and the importance of the game in question. This wasn't one of those games. Sweden could use more from Zibanejad and Petterson but I guess it's a bit hard against Canada's gazillion star centers.

And, of course, nice to see that the Pens players can do very well against the very best. When the coach isn't living in 2016, that is.
 
Snooki Stackhouse said:
Go to any social media post or Reddit thread and you'll see similar types of terminally online people who are emotionally over-invested in a variety of topics. On a forum like this, Crosby - being the face of the NHL for so long - is a lightning rod for that type of negative energy.
Click to expand...
It sounds weird, but I think it’s that some people just don’t have room in their hearts for both of them.

Also, there are a few posters who are super pro-Russia. (OV fans more than anything)
 
Big Friggin Dummy said:
It's fun to watch Sid play with real talent again.
Click to expand...
When did Sid ever play with the likes of Mackinnon? Or for that matter, Marner. Mark Stones of the league he has played with a ton of.

Considering, Geno was rarely on his line and injured just about every season, and Jake being the closest to anything resembling a true top star in the league, when has he ever played with such players since the 2016 world cup where he was named MVP and he was paired with Marchand and Bergeron with both young McDavid and Mackinnon playing only 3 games each asks when did he ever play with such high elite generational talent on his line. Mack wasn't who he is for a couple years, and McDavid was a rookie.

Answer is: Never.
 
Ugene Magic said:
When did Sid ever play with the likes of Mackinnon? Or for that matter, Marner. Mark Stones of the league he has played with a ton of.

Considering, Geno was rarely on his line and injured just about every season, and Jake being the closest to anything resembling a true top star in the league, when has he ever played with such players since the 2016 world cup where he was named MVP and he was paired with Marchand and Bergeron with both young McDavid and Mackinnon playing only 3 games each asks when did he ever play with such high elite generational talent on his line. Mack wasn't who he is for a couple years, and McDavid was a rookie.

Answer is: Never.
Click to expand...
Well very few elite players ever play with top 5-10 players in the league on their line - maybe McDavid and Draistl but that's about it. The best player Sid played with was probably Hossa.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Buddy Bizarre and Ugene Magic
Sid on another team is an MVP candidate. If anything the tournament is showing how much he’s sacrificing being on a sinking ship.
 
Snooki Stackhouse said:
Go to any social media post or Reddit thread and you'll see similar types of terminally online people who are emotionally over-invested in a variety of topics. On a forum like this, Crosby - being the face of the NHL for so long - is a lightning rod for that type of negative energy.
Click to expand...
I get that, but I would think it would still be a little more even on hfb. Like, he's Canada and has done amazing things for Canada internationally, but this site, specifically, makes it out like he's a bum
 
MrBrightside said:
Ah, my bad. Can't recall who Sid played with in Vancouver or Sochi but I presume Bergeron and Marchand in Sochi...but that could be wrong.
Click to expand...

IIRC it was Nash-Crosby-Iginla in Vancouver and Kunitz-Crosby-Bergeron in Socchi.

I remember that Crosby had such difficulty finding chemistry with linemates in Vancouver that they brought Kunitz to the 2014 Olympics in Socchi. It's funny now because it seems like the complete opposite, Crosby seems to mesh immediately with talented linemates at the international level now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom