Toggle sidebar

For a team that is 55 years old soon, is there a worse list of defenseman?

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
  • We are currently aware of "log in/security error" issues that are affecting some users. We apologize and ask for your patience as we try to get these issues fixed.
Status
Not open for further replies.
  • Like
Reactions: JohanFranzenstein and njdevils1982
ESH said:
Carolina/Hartford is a whole lot worse
Click to expand...
Carolina feels like the example of actual defensive defensemen vs high point scorers. Still had some decent names come through even if it was only a few seasons. Canucks are bleak. OEL is about as big as you can go for someone who had a cup of coffee there who was a starish at some point before then.

Slavin, Faulk, Wesley, Howe, Burns, Hamilton, Hanifin, Ozolinsh, Sekera, Coffey, Orlov, Teverdovsky, Hatcher, Ulf, Pronger.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joe McGrath
an abridged history of vancouver canucks dmen, one nut punch after another:

in our first draft, buffalo got the first pick — gilbert perreault — and we got dale tallon number two

one year later, guy lafleur went first, marcel dionne went second, we got jocelyn guevremont with the third pick

in overtime of game one of the finals, the best dman of our first two decades, harry snepsts, makes the most memorable play of his career

we had to employ jim benning on our blueline

our first true all-star calibre dman was broken down paul reinhart, who even with chronic back pain still was able to help push his old team, the powerhouse calgary flames, to game seven OT before otto “scored," kicking off their cup run

mattias ohlund, our first homegrown dman with number one stud potential, caught a puck in the eye in preseason before his third year and suffered a career-altering eye injury, losing a third of his vision in one eye

we had young adrian aucoin, traded him for dan cloutier

four teams ahead of us in the 2005 draft go for crazy reaches, leaving kopitar to fall to us and we take luc bourdon

luc bourdon dies tragically in a motorcycle accident, RIP

we had to employ jim benning as our GM, and he replaced jason garrison with luca sbisa, kevin bieksa with alex biega, dan hamhuis with erik gudbranson, chris tanev with tyler myers, alex edler with OEL’s cap hit and corpse, and for good measure traded young gus forsling for someone named adam clendening

with matthew tkachuk next up on everybody’s draft list, we select with the fifth pick of the 2016 draft from the london knights olli juolevi

in so many ways the hockey gods owed us quinn hughes
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Haha
Reactions: Diversification, GrogZilla, GreatSaveLuongo and 3 others
Fatass said:
And they wouldn’t have Hughes if not for clubs making big mistakes in his draft. Imagine a pairing of Hughes and Seider! The Wings would be off to the races.
Click to expand...

hughes and hronek on one pair, seider on the other pair to fill out a stout top four :naughty:
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Fatass
vadim sharifijanov said:
an abridged history of vancouver canucks dmen:

in our first draft, buffalo got the first pick — gilbert perreault — and we got dale tallon number two

one year later, guy lafleur went first, marcel dionne went second, we got jocelyn guevremont with the third pick

this is the most memorable play in the career of the best dmen of our first two decades, harry snepsts

we had to employ jim benning on our blueline

our first true all-star calibre dman was broken down paul reinhart, who even with chronic back pain still was able to help push his old team, the powerhouse calgary flames, to game seven OT before otto “scored," kicking off their cup run

mattias ohlund, our first homegrown dman with number one stud potential, caught a puck in the eye in preseason before his third year and suffered a career-altering eye injury, losing a third of his vision in one eye

we had young adrian aucoin, traded him for dan cloutier

we had to employ jim benning as our GM, and he replaced jason garrison with luca sbisa, kevin bieksa with alex biega, dan hamhuis with erik gudbranson, chris tanev with tyler myers, alex edler with OEL’s cap hit and corpse, and for good measure traded young gus forsling for someone named adam clendening

in so many ways the hockey gods owed us quinn hughes
Click to expand...

To be fair, they did have Rory Fitzpatrick.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Diversification, David Bruce Banner, Hennessy and 1 other person
Albatros said:
Whippersnapper. Lumme, Jovanovski, Öhlund, Salo, Bieksa, Ehrhoff, Edler, Hamhuis were all very good or in some cases outright elite there. Aucoin and Sopel had pretty good years too even if it wasn't the whole picture. Even before they were any good as a team they had guys like McCarthy, Lanz, Reinhart.
Click to expand...
Your bar for “elite” is laughably low, sorry.

The guys you list, while all good players in their own right, were never in the conversation for personal hardware, weren’t NHL all stars, and were at best second or third fiddle on their national teams (or were the top dog for a week country like Erhoff for Germany).
 
Last edited:
Zenos said:
Your bar for “elite” is laughably low, sorry.

The guys you list, while all good players in their own right, were never in the conversation for personal hardware, weren’t NHL all stars, and were at best second or third fiddle on their national teams (or were the top dog for a week country like Edler).
Click to expand...
Jovanovski for one was back-to-back 6th in the Norris vote, if he wasn't elite then you didn't have more than at most five elite defensemen in the league.

And Edler was a two-time World Champion and Olympic silver medalist with Sweden, very weak they weren't.
 
Zenos said:
Your bar for “elite” is laughably low, sorry.

The guys you list, while all good players in their own right, were never in the conversation for personal hardware, weren’t NHL all stars, and were at best second or third fiddle on their national teams (or were the top dog for a week country like Edler).
Click to expand...
Edler was never top dog for Sweden. Which isn't exactly a weak hockey country, either.
 
Albatros said:
Jovanovski for one was back-to-back 6th in the Norris vote, if he wasn't elite then you didn't have more than at most five elite defensemen in the league.

And Edler was a two-time World Champion and Olympic silver medalist with Sweden, very weak they weren't.
Click to expand...
I meant Erhoff, not Edler.

Jovo at his peak was the best from your list.
 
Hennessy said:
Edler was never top dog for Sweden. Which isn't exactly a weak hockey country, either.
Click to expand...
I was thinking Erhoff the whole time and made a gaff, typing Edler.

But you’re absolutely right and that was kind of my point. All the deeper teams had players above Edler, Hamhuis, Jovo, etc on their rosters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hennessy
Soundgarden said:
Man, I'm trying to think of a single really good Whale defenseman. I know they had Burt and Babych just from my older brothers hockey card collection.
Click to expand...
I know it doesn’t really count, but the Pronger was drafted there.

Mark Howe was a also Whaler in the WHA and in their early NHL existence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Soundgarden
Ehrhoff has Olympic silver as well with Germany, and made the World Cup final as a key part of the so-called Team Europe.
 
Bjornar Moxnes said:
Ohlund was a monster.
Click to expand...

He might have had some Norris contention seasons, if he hadn't suffered a serious eye injury in his sophomore season. That eye was never 100% again. In his notorious incident vs. Koivu I think he snapped because he thought Koivu targeted his bad eye with the butt-end of his stick.

But, yeah... with regards to this thread and real life performances. The Canucks had some good defencemen over the years, and some entertaining ones, but none who were ever in the serious discussion as one of the best in the league at any given time. It was 5 decades of "good enough" at best.
 
There are some really good players on that list. Jovocop, Edler, Ohlund and Lumme to name a couple were legit top pairing guys at their best.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom