Fire Tocchet #2

Should Tocchet be fired?


  • Total voters
    105

RemoAZ

Let it burn
Mar 30, 2010
11,232
7,629
Glendale, Arizona
I can’t believe they haven’t fired him this morning. This is really unbelievable.
Bill may be doing unofficial interviews ahead of time. He may not think any of the assistants are head coaches he wants. In that case, unless he has a candidate he is ready to make a move on, firing Tocc might not be worth it right now.
 

Grimes

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Jan 5, 2012
8,680
5,202
Tippet's Doghouse
cleanhits.substack.com
Bill may be doing unofficial interviews ahead of time. He may not think any of the assistants are head coaches he wants. In that case, unless he has a candidate he is ready to make a move on, firing Tocc might not be worth it right now.

I truly don't see how it can't be worth it.

You signed a 5 year contract to be a GM for a team. You have a coach on an expiring deal who hasn't had one .500% winning season in four years. You are still trying to evaluate players before going into an important offseason that potentially will have lots of movement because of the expansion draft. You also need to know if the team should be adding pieces in free agency, trade or hold tight and hope we finally luck out a little in the 2022 draft. You have the perfect opportunity to evaluate this young core with both a coach that many praise around the league, and without him. You can have a control of this is how the team looks with RT, this is how it looks without. You can see if certain players shine or slump both with or without him. If you keep RT until the end of the season you don't get to evaluate the team this way. If you don't fire him you have to hope he wants to re-sign if you want him to stick around (rumors claim he doesn't) or you have to hope that RT was the problem and not the core.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rt

BUX7PHX

Registered User
Jul 7, 2011
5,581
1,350


^ I’d say it’s time for Tocchet to face some “adversity”. He needs to be let go today. This morning. Within the next 90minutes.


The statement, "You've just got to come out of it."

I just had to laugh at that, envisioning Tocchet as the hospital preacher on Scrubs talking to a family/individual in a coma:

"This is an adverse situation. Can't open eyes or move. Doctors doing everything they can to work a miracle. But when things are adverse, sometimes you just got to come out of it."

Even in those medical situations, things are being done behind the scenes. Maybe experimental treatments, or understanding what the cause may be to determine the likelihood of coming out of it. I don't know if we have am experimental treatment for coaching to even bring forth.
 

cobra427

Registered User
May 6, 2012
9,383
3,421
I truly don't see how it can't be worth it.

You signed a 5 year contract to be a GM for a team. You have a coach on an expiring deal who hasn't had one .500% winning season in four years. You are still trying to evaluate players before going into an important offseason that potentially will have lots of movement because of the expansion draft. You also need to know if the team should be adding pieces in free agency, trade or hold tight and hope we finally luck out a little in the 2022 draft. You have the perfect opportunity to evaluate this young core with both a coach that many praise around the league, and without him. You can have a control of this is how the team looks with RT, this is how it looks without. You can see if certain players shine or slump both with or without him. If you keep RT until the end of the season you don't get to evaluate the team this way. If you don't fire him you have to hope he wants to re-sign if you want him to stick around (rumors claim he doesn't) or you have to hope that RT was the problem and not the core.
Our playoff hopes are all but lost at this point. Pick an assistant, let him take over, we might have a better shot at the playoffs. As you said, we get a look at players and how they perform with a different leader. There have been too many players that come to Az and get worse, while others go elsewhere and play better. It seems like the pending UFAs in Goose/Demers/Hjam would want to play well with a contract coming. Its so obvious OEL doesn't play well for RT.

The last 3 years plus this year should be enough for BA to know he has to make a coaching change. If they liked RT, they would have extended him before now. Give Varardy the interim title, doesn't cost anything, nothing to lose, this summer you can pick the permanent coach. I don't get it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surfshop

SpaceCoyote

Registered User
Jul 10, 2013
612
384
Wasting away
Want him gone as much as anyone here, but I'm not too surprised he is still here. Armstrong actually praised the team's performance against the Avs on his Monday morning radio interview. So to him this has just been a bad 3 game stretch.
 

RemoAZ

Let it burn
Mar 30, 2010
11,232
7,629
Glendale, Arizona
Yeah it’s not going to happen. They’re deathly afraid of bad PR. They’re going wait until a week or two after the season and announce they are not retaining him at 10pm on a Friday, and that will be it.
True. If they weren't afraid of bad PR we'd still have our top draft pick from last season and probably DeAngelo too.
 

Foggy1097

Registered User
Jan 14, 2014
2,515
2,405
Arizona
True. If they weren't afraid of bad PR we'd still have our top draft pick from last season and probably DeAngelo too.

Yeah and you know what, that’d be fine by me. If they do wrong by you once they’re in your organization then you do what you have to do, but not giving people a chance because you don’t want bad press is pretty cowardly if you ask me. The fact that a player as talented as DeAngelo isn’t even playing on a team right now should tell you exactly where our culture is at the moment.
 

The Feckless Puck

Registered Loser
Sponsor
Oct 26, 2006
18,751
12,006
The fact that a player as talented as DeAngelo isn’t even playing on a team right now should tell you exactly where our culture is at the moment.

Tells me more about just how toxic he is as a person, honestly. Because you can say what you want about the culture wars, but pro sports exercise way more leeway in those regards because of precisely what you mentioned - player talent. A truly talented player receives near-endless largesse, and only when their misbehavior gets really egregious does the hammer fall.
 

Foggy1097

Registered User
Jan 14, 2014
2,515
2,405
Arizona
Tells me more about just how toxic he is as a person, honestly. Because you can say what you want about the culture wars, but pro sports exercise way more leeway in those regards because of precisely what you mentioned - player talent. A truly talented player receives near-endless largesse, and only when their misbehavior gets really egregious does the hammer fall.

Those are just outside assumptions. He’s had multiple NYR teammates publicly state they think it’s been overblown and can’t understand why he’s not playing. It used to be the way you’re talking about but it isn’t that way anymore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BigJCaRoach

TeamTourigny

Formally TeamTurris & TeamTippet & TeamTocchet
Jan 16, 2007
5,411
91
Vegas
Toc has to be protected by ownership for some reason. That is the only logical conclusion at this point.
 

The Feckless Puck

Registered Loser
Sponsor
Oct 26, 2006
18,751
12,006
He’s had multiple NYR teammates publicly state they think it’s been overblown and can’t understand why he’s not playing.

Almost every bad actor has allies, especially in pro sports. Unless a player is a recluse or loner type, he'll have some teammates who will side with him no matter the behavior.

But the larger issue is this - if Tony DeAngelo wasn't on his final strike in NHL circles, he'd absolutely 100% be playing somewhere no matter what he did in the past, because of the ever-present belief in reclamation projects. The only way that wouldn't be true is if he came out and publicly criticized the league for his issues, like Dan Carcillo did. That's the unforgivable sin among the Boys' Club.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad