fedorov vs sundin

[Ulysses31]

this 1 is super close IMO.

who was the better player overall throughout their careers?

 

[ESH]

It’s Fedorov and it’s really not that close

 

[wetcoast]

I really like Sundin but Fedorov was simply a better player.

 

[Ulysses31]

red wings fan here, but i think sundin was at least better offensively

on other hand, fedorov's 2-way game hurt his offensive output

 

[ScaredStreit]

Fedorov by a country mile.

 

[chamchibap]

I love Mats and he’s my greatest leaf of all time, but Fedorov was consistently one of the best in the league and I don’t think Mats reached those same heights

 

[SirPaste]

This is Federov easy

 

[blinkman360]

Imagine drafting Fedorov and Lidstrom in the same draft? Imagine neither of them cost you a 1st or a 2nd rounder? That still blows my mind to this day.

 

[Coffee]

Imagine drafting Fedorov and Lidstrom in the same draft? Imagine neither of them cost you a 1st or a 2nd rounder? That still blows my mind to this day.

@Ulysses31 does not need to imagine it

 

[Spawn]

Fedorov. Not a huge gap, but a decisive one.

 

[Regal]

Imagine drafting Fedorov and Lidstrom in the same draft? Imagine neither of them cost you a 1st or a 2nd rounder? That still blows my mind to this day.

Imagine drafting two players who played 1000 games in the league and another who was a Norris runner up all in the same draft and none of them are one of the best two players you drafted that year

 

[DrDangles]

Fedorov's peak gives him the edge, but Sundin was better on the back half of his career. Sundin's longevity and consistency is extremely rare, especially considering the era he played through.

 

[FMichael]

I personally feel that Fedorov was more talented, but at times lacked the effort/was moody while Sundin appeared to work his butt off on a nightly basis.

 

[blinkman360]

Imagine drafting two players who played 1000 games in the league and another who was a Norris runner up all in the same draft and none of them are one of the best two players you drafted that year

Has any draft ever rivaled that? I'm trying to think of another where two HOFers were drafted by the same team, even if they were in the 1st round, but nothing comes to mind. I remember Kopitar and Quick were in the same draft, although - as great as they are - they obviously come nowhere close to Fedorov and Lidstrom. Other than that I'm drawing blanks.

 

[Sasha Orlov]

I don’t see how this is remotely close tbh

 

[BraveCanadian]

Fedorov by a significant margin.

Feds had a much higher peak, was better defensively throughout their careers, and was a much much better playoff performer.

Sundin maybe has some extra good seasons over their career spans due to his consistency but that’s about it.

 

[Sasso09]

this 1 is super close IMO.

who was the better player overall throughout their careers?

Not remotely close