Toggle sidebar

F Fraser Minten (2022, 38, TOR)

  • PLEASE check any bookmark on all devices. IF you see a link pointing to mandatory.com DELETE it Please use this URL https://forums.hfboards.com/
TheKrebsCycle

TheKrebsCycle

Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
Jun 1, 2011
6,983
2,454
Barrie
EveryDay said:
Lol he was not even top 2.....he was only good on the PP.

Huston was by FAR the best players on the ice today and the 2nd best was Minten.
Click to expand...
Looks like others who also watched the game disagree . You’re welcome to your opinion, but so are they . It’s not inconceivable that Cowan would be the top player given his top prospect status ( I understand that Montreal also have some good looking prospects ) . I didn’t watch for the record just saying , people have different perspectives that lead to different logistical outcomes
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dion TheFluff and BerthMania
BerthMania

BerthMania

Registered User
Jun 3, 2022
287
272
Montréal
Dion TheFluff said:
who would be your top 5 today?
Click to expand...
From Toronto tbh the only players I knew were Minton, Cowan and Niemela. I thought Minten and Cowan were the 2 best players of the day, with Cowan being the 1st.

From the Habs side. Hutson did some solid things offensively, but I didn't love his defensive game. I'd still say he was our best player. It was the first time I saw him live and I thought we looked very small and not very strong physicaly. Mailloux and Reinbacher didn't have a very solid outing (but it doesn't mean they're not good, I'll wait for other games to really make my opinion.)

Other then that, I liked Florian Xhekaj for his intensity and grittiness. I saw Adam Engstrom play for the first time, his skating was very impressive, better then I thought, but he didn'T look to be physically very intimidating. I also liked Owen Beck.

So I'd say

#1 Cowan (I thought he was almost always on the ice and I always noticed him. Super fast, hard worker, I'd love to have him on the Habs)
#2 Minten
#3 Hutson
#4 Beck
#5 Engstrom
EveryDay said:
Lol he was not even top 2.....he was only good on the PP.

Huston was by FAR the best players on the ice today and the 2nd best was Minten.
Click to expand...

My opinion isn't the objective truth, I'm just a fan who never really played at a high level, but I'm curious to hear you about Hutson's defensive game today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: weems, Dion TheFluff and bert
TheKrebsCycle

TheKrebsCycle

Throwing Confetti for Perfetti
Jun 1, 2011
6,983
2,454
Barrie
BerthMania said:
From Toronto tbh the only players I knew were Minton, Cowan and Niemela. I thought Minten and Cowan were the 2 best players of the day, with Cowan being the 1st.

From the Habs side. Hutson did some solid things offensively, but I didn't love his defensive game. I'd still say he was our best player. It was the first time I saw him live and I thought we looked very small and not very strong physicaly. Mailloux and Reinbacher didn't have a very solid outing (but it doesn't mean they're not good, I'll wait for other games to really make my opinion.)

Other then that, I liked Florian Xhekaj for his intensity and grittiness. I saw Adam Engstrom play for the first time, his skating was very impressive, better then I thought, but he didn'T look to be physically very intimidating. I also liked Owen Beck.

So I'd say

#1 Cowan (I thought he was almost always on the ice and I always noticed him. Super fast, hard worker, I'd love to have him on the Habs)
#2 Minten
#3 Hutson
#4 Beck
#5 Engstrom


My opinion isn't the objective truth, I'm just a fan who never really played at a high level, but I'm curious to hear you about Hutson's defensive game.
Click to expand...
Thank you for this . Seems like a very reasonable evaluation. We’re excited for Cowan but he’s really the only blue chip prospect we have . Be interesting to see if he sticks . Not much left to prove in Jr. AHL would be perfect but alas .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dion TheFluff
Just Linda

Just Linda

Registered User
Feb 24, 2018
6,788
6,752
BerthMania said:
From Toronto tbh the only players I knew were Minton, Cowan and Niemela. I thought Minten and Cowan were the 2 best players of the day, with Cowan being the 1st.

From the Habs side. Hutson did some solid things offensively, but I didn't love his defensive game. I'd still say he was our best player. It was the first time I saw him live and I thought we looked very small and not very strong physicaly. Mailloux and Reinbacher didn't have a very solid outing (but it doesn't mean they're not good, I'll wait for other games to really make my opinion.)

Other then that, I liked Florian Xhekaj for his intensity and grittiness. I saw Adam Engstrom play for the first time, his skating was very impressive, better then I thought, but he didn'T look to be physically very intimidating. I also liked Owen Beck.

So I'd say

#1 Cowan (I thought he was almost always on the ice and I always noticed him. Super fast, hard worker, I'd love to have him on the Habs)
#2 Minten
#3 Hutson
#4 Beck
#5 Engstrom


My opinion isn't the objective truth, I'm just a fan who never really played at a high level, but I'm curious to hear you about Hutson's defensive game today.
Click to expand...

Not too far off from what I saw.

I had Minten above Cowen just because of some of the defensive breakups that Minten had. I also had Thorpe for the Habs higher up, he had some bad reads but also had some good separations before he got hurt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BerthMania
Just Linda

Just Linda

Registered User
Feb 24, 2018
6,788
6,752
I'll be the controversial one I guess.

I don't think think he has 3c upside. I don't think asking him to play 3c is realistic to him or his game....

I expect more than that. I think he's got a 20% chance of being a 2c. I don't think he'll ever be the most productive player but he's going to be effective. He'll be a great Danault type player.
 
HockeyVirus

HockeyVirus

Woll stan.
Nov 15, 2020
18,086
27,718
Just Linda said:
I'll be the controversial one I guess.

I don't think think he has 3c upside. I don't think asking him to play 3c is realistic to him or his game....

I expect more than that. I think he's got a 20% chance of being a 2c. I don't think he'll ever be the most productive player but he's going to be effective. He'll be a great Danault type player.
Click to expand...

He is one of the players scouting the boxscore isn't that great of a tell of his story and impact on the game. Very smart player
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dion TheFluff and Just Linda
Just Linda

Just Linda

Registered User
Feb 24, 2018
6,788
6,752
HockeyVirus said:
He is one of the players scouting the boxscore isn't that great of a tell of his story and impact on the game. Very smart player
Click to expand...

Very smart but also a possession monster.

He's got to get stronger for sure but you could stick him on an NHL line right now and he'd be able to play the cycle game. He plays a full NHL style.

A lot of the reason why his point numbers aren't elite is because of how maturely he plays the game. Juniors score off the rush, he didn't play that role.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HockeyVirus
HockeyVirus

HockeyVirus

Woll stan.
Nov 15, 2020
18,086
27,718
Just Linda said:
Very smart but also a possession monster.

He's got to get stronger for sure but you could stick him on an NHL line right now and he'd be able to play the cycle game. He plays a full NHL style.

A lot of the reason why his point numbers aren't elite is because of how maturely he plays the game. Juniors score off the rush, he didn't play that role.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't be shocked if in 5 years he managed to develop into a Danault type of center.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Just Linda
You must log in or register to reply here.

Ad

Latest posts

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

Top Bottom
X