Fleury is actually crazy. I don't even have him above guys like Luongo, Price, Miller, Holtby, Thomas who themselves have no business on this list.
Toews became so "overrated" in peoples eyes he's swung back around to underrated. He should be on this list near the bottom in the 18-25 range IMO.
Hot take alert but if I am drafting them at age 18 knowing what we know now I think I draft Toews over both Thornton and Stamkos. Peak Toews was everything you could ever want in a hockey player.
MAF being on the list is laughable. He shouldn't even be in the top 100, never mind top 25. Talk about a player who lucked out on playing for good teams to improve his reputation dramatically.
And he wasn't even good on those good teams. Very good, cup contending, Pens teams crapped out of the playoffs multiple times almost exclusively due to his poor play.