Toggle sidebar

Epic Calder Race 2024-25

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.
Frank Drebin said:
You do have a dog in the race, you’re just pretending you don’t😉
Click to expand...
This is just the thing that I love to hear, when a clearly biased poster somehow knows my views better than I do?

The term WTF seems pretty reasonable here but then again maybe you think all posters are as biased as you are?

HitHard said:
This.

Hutson has a trajectory to rewrite more than 100 years History in his rookie debuts.

I’m fine with Celebrini, but 25 minutes defenceman with those points > Great rookie forward.
Click to expand...
Except that Hutson isn't even a 23 MPG Dman though right?

Also what history is Hutson going to rewrite this year?

Do you expect him to eclipse 76 points?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Xirik
wetcoast said:
This is just the thing that I love to hear, when a clearly biased poster somehow knows my views better than I do?

The term WTF seems pretty reasonable here but then again maybe you think all posters are as biased as you are?
Click to expand...
What have I said that was biased?
 
Today, Mack wins in a close race.


Imo, if Habs maintain their pace of the past 6 weeks, and Hutson keeps getting better (as he has every month this far), they will make the playoffs and he'll win by a comfortable margin.

But there's a lot of hockey left and things could change for all 3 front runners.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dutronc, waitin425 and Frank Drebin
wetcoast said:
I don't expect you to get it, just like you don't seem to understand clear arguments or statements either.
Click to expand...
so you can't point out anything biased? Its pretty clear that the thought of Hutson winning the Calder bothers you. Downplaying his "fine" season, purposefully ignoring the potential to beat the all time record for assists by a rookie dman, appealing to the PWHA as if their votes really mean anything.

Instead of pointing out how clearly biased I am you start to lean into the personal insults.
 
  • Like
Reactions: viceroy
Frank Drebin said:
so you can't point out anything biased?
Click to expand...
I actually did though.


Frank Drebin said:
Its pretty clear that the thought of Hutson winning the Calder bothers you.
Click to expand...
Why would it bother me, like I said i have no dog in the race and even though I think Celebrini is the better rookie so far, I really have no problem if hutson wins it becasue of an injury to celebrini or he steps up even more and ceelbrini declines in play.

Once again you are trying to state things for me, which kind of of shows your bias again.

I think that I would have a much better idea on my feelings on this thread than you do.


Frank Drebin said:
Downplaying his "fine" season, purposefully ignoring the potential to beat the all time record for assists by a rookie dman, appealing to the PWHA as if their votes really mean anything.
Click to expand...

Sure why would the actual voters feeling right now on the award they will be voting for later this year mean anything?


So what if he breaks 60 assists, his overall play right now is what is being judged as for celebrini as well.

But who knows maybe some voters will be impressed by that.

Also if you want to look back Murphy didn't win the Calder that year when he had 60 assists and he had 16 goals too.

What if he scores 10 goals the rest of the way and only gets 20 more assists does that matter or is the actual overall play and impact the thing that should be judged here?
Frank Drebin said:
Instead of pointing out how clearly biased I am you start to lean into the personal insults.
Click to expand...
You started the bias game here and didn't bother to read my comments and then pretended to speak for me on 2 occasions now so I wouldn't go down that road.
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
GhostfaceWu said:
I know its not calder related but how is fantilli so unimpressive this year
Click to expand...
He is still young but frankly if someone had said that Columbus would be in playoff contention halfway through the year one would think that fantilli's emergence might have been a reason why.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dutronc
NikolaTesla said:
Oh im sorry i must have missed the votes for the 2025 calder trophy :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
Here it is for you again from the people who actually vote on these things.

www.espn.com

NHL Awards Watch: The MVP race tightens up -- and adds more contenders

At the midway mark of the 2024-25 season, are some awards already sewn up? We checked in with a panel of PHWA voters to check the temperature.
www.espn.com www.espn.com

From the article.

After finishing second to Michkov in the December NHL Awards Watch, Celebrini pulled nearly 90% of the first-place votes from our panelists to take control of the rookie of the year race.
Click to expand...
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian and waitin425
wetcoast said:
Here it is for you again from the people who actually vote on these things.

www.espn.com

NHL Awards Watch: The MVP race tightens up -- and adds more contenders

At the midway mark of the 2024-25 season, are some awards already sewn up? We checked in with a panel of PHWA voters to check the temperature.
www.espn.com www.espn.com

From the article.
Click to expand...
Okay they're a whole bunch of idiots or they must be from west coast and don't watch hutson play then. Lets see their votes after the next 42 games. The one that actually matters.
 
NikolaTesla said:
Okay they're a whole bunch of idiots or they must be from west coast and don't watch hutson play then. Lets see their votes after the next 42 games. The one that actually matters.
Click to expand...
Sure your argument is so convincing that..........
 
wetcoast said:
Here it is for you again from the people who actually vote on these things.

www.espn.com

NHL Awards Watch: The MVP race tightens up -- and adds more contenders

At the midway mark of the 2024-25 season, are some awards already sewn up? We checked in with a panel of PHWA voters to check the temperature.
www.espn.com www.espn.com

From the article.
Click to expand...
I appreciate you sharing. And quite frankly I am shocked by this. I have watched a handful of Celebrini's games and agree....he is lights out and a future superstar. Hutson by all measures has also shown he is a future superstar. I scoffed at AINEC @Zegs2sendhelp but clearly his opinion is based bolstered by this apparent polling of PWHA.

With that being said....last night was a huge game for Hutson and had to have swayed some voters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coooldude
NikolaTesla said:
Oh because yours is so good right?
Click to expand...
Well now that you mention it yes I think that a rookie 18 year old center who is playing a great 200 foot game and is close to 505 on the dot and leads all rookies with .93 PPG compared to Hutson at .75 and Michkov at .76.

Celebrini is also playing with less impressive team mates on the ice 5 on 5.

So no I'm not surprised that close to 90% of the voters have him first on their ballots currently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
waitin425 said:
I appreciate you sharing. And quite frankly I am shocked by this. I have watched a handful of Celebrini's games and agree....he is lights out and a future superstar. Hutson by all measures has also shown he is a future superstar. I scoffed at AINEC @Zegs2sendhelp but clearly his opinion is based bolstered by this apparent polling of PWHA.

With that being said....last night was a huge game for Hutson and had to have swayed some voters.
Click to expand...
I havnt read that….

My opinion is based of celebrin being that damn good…. I’d take celebrini over bedard.

Celebrini is best young player in the nhl, not just rookie
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
  • Like
Reactions: Rozz, leopod, viceroy and 3 others
waitin425 said:
I appreciate you sharing. And quite frankly I am shocked by this. I have watched a handful of Celebrini's games and agree....he is lights out and a future superstar. Hutson by all measures has also shown he is a future superstar. I scoffed at AINEC @Zegs2sendhelp but clearly his opinion is based bolstered by this apparent polling of PWHA.
Click to expand...
The thing is that historically Calder voters have really favoured forwards to Dmen and that's apart of it.

That's why I brought up the examples of Lidstrom and Faber last year not winning, Hutson isn't having a better rookie season than either of those guys and my bet is that if Celebrini was doing this last season ahead of Bedard he very well may be beating out Bedard as well but that's a hypothetical.


waitin425 said:
With that being said....last night was a huge game for Hutson and had to have swayed some voters.
Click to expand...
I dunno does one game against the Canucks whose defense has blown leads a lot lately change that much?

I had to go out and was in and out on the broadcast but the goal was fluky and Guhle seemed more impressive but like I said I didn't watch the end of the game as I was out.

All that being said a single game doesn't drive the needle that much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: karltonian
wetcoast said:
Well now that you mention it yes I think that a rookie 18 year old center who is playing a great 200 foot game and is close to 505 on the dot and leads all rookies with .93 PPG compared to Hutson at .75 and Michkov at .76.

Celebrini is also playing with less impressive team mates on the ice 5 on 5.

So no I'm not surprised that close to 90% of the voters have him first on their ballots currently.
Click to expand...
Doesnt Hutson have better defensive numbers? Albeit very similar. Also, .75 ppg as a rookie defensemen is more impressive than .93 as a rookie center. Whos the next best rookie defensemen? So damn far behind.
 
  • Like
Reactions: viceroy and Grate n Colorful Oz
bud12 said:
90% from espn panelists only. Do the same thing with RDS panelist and 90% would chose Hutson.....
Click to expand...
Incorrect although they don't state numbers but they were pretty accurate last year.

We've polled a wide selection of Professional Hockey Writers Association voters anonymously to get a sense of where the wind is blowing for the current leaders. We've made sure it's a cross-section from the entire league, trying to gain as many perspectives as possible.
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
NikolaTesla said:
Doesnt Hutson have better defensive numbers? Albeit very similar. Also, .75 ppg as a rookie defensemen is more impressive than .93 as a rookie center. Whos the next best rookie defensemen? So damn far behind.
Click to expand...
Sure but then again how many of the voters look at which analytic numbers?

Sure on the surface a regular forward at a .93 PPG compared to dman at .75 means something but most rookie forwards, in fact I'm trying to remember the last one that is recent maybe Toews/Kopitar, don't have that 200 foot game either.

I also think that some voters are going to look at Celebrini having 20 ESP points compared to Hutson's 17 as an advantage for Celebrini.

NikolaTesla said:
Oh that article is espn only? Makes sense now lol.
Click to expand...
No you're jumping the gun read the post above the one you made.

Post #1249
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom