Epic Calder Battle in 2024-25 Season

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Honestly if he stays healthy it’s celebrini, AINEC.

Was underrated at the draft, he looks like he’s going to be better than bedard …. A winners mentality and work ethic.


Out of all the young stars in the league, he’s easily the guy you want to build around if winning is your end goal.

 

[FerrisRox]

Celebrini is carrying his linemates. Michkov is being carried.

This is a hilariously clueless take.

Completely out to lunch on this one.

I will never understand why people come here and give authoritative takes on players that they *clearly* don't watch. You're going to be exposed instantly. You might be able to get away with dumb things like this in the break room at work where there's a good chance nobody watches Flyers games, but at this place, where all the fan bases are represented, and many people have NHL packages and watch all kinds of games? You're gonna get called out right away for obvious lies.

 

[zombie kopitar]

This is a hilariously clueless take.

Completely out to lunch on this one.

I will never understand why people come here and give authoritative takes on players that they *clearly* don't watch. You're going to be exposed instantly. You might be able to get away with dumb things like this in the break room at work where there's a good chance nobody watches Flyers games, but at this place, where all the fan bases are represented, and many people have NHL packages and watch all kinds of games? You're gonna get called out right away for obvious lies.

Whoosh. Someone was being intentionally hyperbolic to match the energy of someone else in this thread

 

[Patty Ice]

This is a hilariously clueless take.

This poster is our board's version of Sean Avery. He sustains himself on reactions like these.

 

[Star Platinum]

This is a hilariously clueless take.

Completely out to lunch on this one.

I will never understand why people come here and give authoritative takes on players that they *clearly* don't watch. You're going to be exposed instantly. You might be able to get away with dumb things like this in the break room at work where there's a good chance nobody watches Flyers games, but at this place, where all the fan bases are represented, and many people have NHL packages and watch all kinds of games? You're gonna get called out right away for obvious lies.

Satire detector on the fritz?

 

[Casper The Soy Ghost]

Honestly if he stays healthy it’s celebrini, AINEC.

Was underrated at the draft, he looks like he’s going to be better than bedard …. A winners mentality and work ethic.


Out of all the young stars in the league, he’s easily the guy you want to build around if winning is your end goal.

Underrated? He was the favorite to go 1 st overall (?)... looks great though!

 

[zombie kopitar]

Underrated? He was the favorite to go 1 st overall (?)... looks great though!

A lot of speculation had him ranked closer to Carlsson and Fantilli than Bedard; and obviously he right now is running away from all 3 (key words being 'right now')

 

[Jabba11]

Celebrini is carrying his linemates. Michkov is being carried.

What a poor take. I've been to 3 Flyers game so far this season, Michkov is creating so much for the Flyers, he's the team MVP so far this season, on and off the ice. So yeah, he's not being carried.

With that being said, Lane Hutson will win the Calder. Merci bonsoir

 

[Mattb124]

This is a hilariously clueless take.

Completely out to lunch on this one.

I will never understand why people come here and give authoritative takes on players that they *clearly* don't watch. You're going to be exposed instantly. You might be able to get away with dumb things like this in the break room at work where there's a good chance nobody watches Flyers games, but at this place, where all the fan bases are represented, and many people have NHL packages and watch all kinds of games? You're gonna get called out right away for obvious lies.

He probably takes a hard pass on watching east coast games so you are justified in dismissing his opinion.

 

[Bizz]

This poster is our board's version of Sean Avery. He sustains himself of reactions like these.

The best part is I'm never wrong.

 

[tiburon12]

I'm a Sharks fan with a soft spot for the Flyers. I'm going the rest of the season on these facts:

• Celebrini is going to be a superstar 3-zones center, Michkov is going to a superstar scoring winger.
• Both have super high value, both are crazy fun to watch. Both are elevating their teams.
• Teams play in different conferences and will likely never play in the cup finals.
• The calder doesn't matter at all.

 

[Fraser28]

I'm a Sharks fan with a soft spot for the Flyers. I'm going the rest of the season on these facts:

• Celebrini is going to be a superstar 3-zones center, Michkov is going to a superstar scoring winger.
• Both have super high value, both are crazy fun to watch. Both are elevating their teams.
• Teams play in different conferences and will likely never play in the cup finals.
• The calder doesn't matter at all.

I agree with all your points except the last. Lots of things don’t matter to the players, but they do to fans. That’s the fun of sports.

 

[CanadienShark]

As an outsider watching this, really nice rookie class this year with Celebrini, Michkov and Hutson

Stankoven, Smith, Wolf too. Yeah, it's stacked.

 

[CanadienShark]

Dude is going to be a selke contender as a rookie. What can't he do?

We haven't seen him coach yet.

 

[tiburon12]

I agree with all your points except the last. Lots of things don’t matter to the players, but they do to fans. That’s the fun of sports.

sure, but ultimately the Calder is forgotten immediately after it is awarded. Did Oilers fans care that a mid-20s Panarin beat McDavid for the Calder during the following season? No.

IMO Calder is just a fun way of celebrating a new class of Rookies. debating over who should win has always been trivial.

 

[Patty Ice]

sure, but ultimately the Calder is forgotten immediately after it is awarded.

I forget that Nabokov won it until I'm reminded when it's brought up as trivia.

 

[ellja3]

I'm a Sharks fan with a soft spot for the Flyers. I'm going the rest of the season on these facts:

• Celebrini is going to be a superstar 3-zones center, Michkov is going to a superstar scoring winger.
• Both have super high value, both are crazy fun to watch. Both are elevating their teams.
• Teams play in different conferences and will likely never play in the cup finals.
• The calder doesn't matter at all.

Never ever ever or never in the span of potential Michkov vs Celebrini? Altho, as a PHI fan, I am ready for the worst.

 

[Grate n Colorful Oz]

Imagine... the Sharks could've had all three of Celebrini, Michkov and Hutson. Damn that would've been an incredible haul.

 

[Barrie22]

Imagine... the Sharks could've had all three of Celebrini, Michkov and Hutson. Damn that would've been an incredible haul.

Still would rather have smith, celebrini, Dickinson. Center depth is better then winger depth.

 

[FlyguyOX]

sure, but ultimately the Calder is forgotten immediately after it is awarded. Did Oilers fans care that a mid-20s Panarin beat McDavid for the Calder during the following season? No.

IMO Calder is just a fun way of celebrating a new class of Rookies. debating over who should win has always been trivial.

I definitely cared that an old-ass Panarin beat Gostisbehere

Celebrini rocking the Bedard special, being a negative player.