Elias Pettersson or Jack Hughes?

[Breakers]

You're free to post something that disputes it.

EDIT:

Just for you. Or are all models crap when they show something you don't agree with?

Literally not his card
LOL

first dead giveaway, he didnt play 82 games.

 

[Buck Naked]

Literally not his card
LOL

first dead giveaway, he didnt play 82 games.

It absolutely is. It's a projection over 82 games based of off what he did during his first 44 games. As you can see, it says Generated: 2023-01-18 at the bottom, which is the "first dead giveaway" you should've been looking for. Nice try though!

 

[Coffee]

It absolutely is. It's a projection over 82 games based of off what he did during his first 44 games.

It’s a fun game of parameters.

 

[WTG]

Fun poll considering they are both league leaders!

 

[Coffee]

Fun poll considering they are both league leaders!

View attachment 756194

And let NHL tell it, NHL breaks the tie in favour of Hughes.


On a serious note, cool to see. NHL’s future in full force

 

[Regal]

It absolutely is. It's a projection over 82 games based of off what he did during his first 44 games. As you can see, it says Generated: 2023-01-18 at the bottom, which is the "first dead giveaway" you should've been looking for. Nice try though!

Just for reference, this is his final card

 

[Felidae]

Petterson was better last year. Same offensive production. Petterson finished 9th in PPG while Hughes was right behind him. But Petterson had the defensive edge, finishing 7th in selke voting while Hughes got no consideration for the award.

That being said, Hughes is 3 years younger, and Petterson was nowhere near that level at the same age. I think the evidence points to Hughes having the higher offensive potential, which might be realized as soon as this season.

I personally see Petterson being a selke contender or just on the outside for the duration of his prime, and I can't say the same for Hughes at the moment. But, I believe defensive acumen is overall easier to teach than the higher offensive ceiling that Hughes has. For that reason, im going with Hughes. But it's not an answer I'm overly confident in.

 

[Coffee]

Petterson was better last year. Same offensive production. Petterson finished 9th in PPG while Hughes was right behind him. But Petterson had the defensive edge, finishing 7th in selke voting while Hughes got no consideration for the award.

That being said, Hughes is 3 years younger, and Petterson was nowhere near that level at the same age. I think the evidence points to Hughes having the higher offensive potential, which might be realized as soon as this season.

I personally see Petterson being a selke contender or just on the outside for the duration of his prime, and I can't say the same for Hughes at the moment. But, I believe defensive acumen is overall easier to teach than the higher offensive ceiling that Hughes has. For that reason, im going with Hughes. But it's not an answer I'm overly confident in.

Great post.

Also what baby animal is that in your picture ?

 

[34]

Jack and it’s not close.

 

[Breakers]

It absolutely is. It's a projection over 82 games based of off what he did during his first 44 games. As you can see, it says Generated: 2023-01-18 at the bottom, which is the "first dead giveaway" you should've been looking for. Nice try though!

And look at his real card
Funny why you didn’t post the that
Embarrassing to post a projection off a season that has happened

 

[Buck Naked]

And look at his real card
Funny why you didn’t post the that
Embarrassing to post a projection off a season that has happened

I don't pay for that kind of shit and therefore didn't have access to it. Just took what I found of off Google.

You don't believe in them though, so what does it matter to you that the number is lesser? You're just in here trying hard at being a dick.

 

[Breakers]

You don't believe in them though, so what does it matter to you that the number is lesser?

Never said that, learn to keep up

And now you’re saying what does it matter. You can’t even keep your arguments straight after posting wrong data

LOL

 

[TBF1972]

And let NHL tell it, NHL breaks the tie in favour of Hughes.

one game less with more goals

 

[wetcoast]

I don't pay for that kind of shit and therefore didn't have access to it. Just took what I found of off Google.

You don't believe in them though, so what does it matter to you that the number is lesser? You're just in here trying hard at being a dick.

I think many would agree with the first part of your statement but then wonder why post those cards at all?


There is more nuance to evaluating players than pulling out some random stat cards.

 

[Felidae]

Great post.

Also what baby animal is that in your picture ?

Thanks, and its a Florida panther cub!

 

[KevinRedkey]

Yes, good for him. He's considered more valuable given his contract status and being younger.
Nothing more.

Most consider EP to the better player. Both are in the same tier as of now.

Inccorect, but keep telling yourself that. lol

 

[Janvonpobben]

Inccorect, but keep telling yourself that. lol

One player actually plays defense.

 

[Janvonpobben]

I just noticed. Hughes is 0.85ppg and petersson 1.01ppg in their careers.

Convenient that people brought up pettersons down year when hughes sucked all seasons but last one

 

[KevinRedkey]

One player actually plays defense.

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

 

[Janvonpobben]

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

1.01ppg >>> 0.85ppg career says othervise

 

[KevinRedkey]

1.01ppg >>> 0.85ppg career says othervise

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

 

[Janvonpobben]

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

Pettersson has produced better ppg and plays more defense.

Going by contract hughes is the better choice. Going by career it is pettersson.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Pettersson has produced better ppg and plays more defense.

Going by contract hughes is the better choice. Going by career it is pettersson.

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

 

[Janvonpobben]

Yet the statement I quoted is still wrong.

Keep telling yourself that.

 

[KevinRedkey]

Keep telling yourself that.

Ok