Confirmed with Link: [EDM/BUF] McLeod + Tullio for Matt Savoie

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,933
16,130
Edmonton, Alberta
I think at the end of the day, regardless of how good McLeod and Tullio are, this trade comes down to Matthew Savoie. If he pans out its a big deal. So... how good, really, is Savoie? I dont know exactly. Camp could be eye opening.
How good? Best points per game season besides Bedard in the WHL in the past 23 years.

Their board is actually more mixed about the trade than I thought it would be. Only about half of them hate it. I think the other half are just impatient and want to see Adams make moves.

In fairness, it does seem like Buffalo keeps drafting the same type of forwards.
I too remember when a desperate Oilers fan base tried to convince themselves trades like Hall for Larsson, and many others were good trades when they got completely hosed. That's really all that is.
 

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,933
16,130
Edmonton, Alberta
Very. The guys certainly doesn’t play with a lot of balls.
But the reality of the trade is this. Oilers traded an actual solid nhl,r who is young and decent at what he does for a bit of a lottery ticket who really hasn’t being going in the right direction.
I really like the trade. But it’s hardly a gimme.
Please explain the bolded. Savoie just put up a 2.09ppg season in the WHL in his draft+2.
 

SupremeTeam16

5-14-6-1
May 31, 2013
8,875
8,852
Baker’s Bay
It’s funny because there’s quite a few around here who thought McLeod had no value and wanted to dump him. He’s possesses a lot of good traits that NHL teams value and he will be missed. But you can find those traits a lot easier then the type of skill and smarts that Savoie has in spades. His size and injuries are definitely a concern but I think it’s a good bet that he’s smart enough to overcome his size. Kid is probably going to be motivated because there’s a real opportunity for a player of his skill to join a strong team as a very cheap option, in his hometown no less. Hopefully he watches a guy like Arvidsson a lot.

This is such a proactive trade, moving out a player who hurts to lose but is replaceable and is going to get more expensive after next year and getting a guy that is a good bet to give you at least a couple cheap productive years over the next 2-4 years and probably retain decent value in that time.
 

Pass the Saitl Sauce

Registered User
Apr 30, 2015
2,267
4,247
Very. The guys certainly doesn’t play with a lot of balls.
But the reality of the trade is this. Oilers traded an actual solid nhl,r who is young and decent at what he does for a bit of a lottery ticket who really hasn’t being going in the right direction.
I really like the trade. But it’s hardly a gimme.
A lot of people would have taken McLeod for cap space, the lottery ticket is just a sweet bonus
 

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,933
16,130
Edmonton, Alberta
Holloway and Broberg still need contracts so it's more like ~2M over the cap still.

It's probably possible to just make it work by playing hardball with them and waiving everyone else but I'd expect another move honestly.
Broberg and Holloway's QO's are 874.125k (1.74825M). They are currently 354.167K over the cap with 21 roster players. If you sent down Josh Brown and Perry (2.15M) you would be cap compliant with 47.583K cap space on a 21 man roster.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 48g90a138pts

Shizuka

Registered User
Mar 16, 2002
3,685
1,629
In purgatory
People keep citing injury history, but does Savoie have any actual injury history outside of his injury in rookie camp last year? Looks like he played two full seasons in the WHL before this without any injuries.
Not sure I understand this either. He played full seasons the two prior to last season. Furthermore, he came back and continued to rip it up, and even in the rehab stint with Rochester still managed 5 pts. in 6 GP (albeit with far better talents than what he'll see in BAK, depending). Shoulder injuries are tough to deal with but he came back and produced at the same astounding clip.
 

Da McBomb

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Dec 9, 2004
8,287
12,824
Just watched a whole lot of Savoie highlights. Damn he is skilled and has a nice shot. Can't wait to follow his progress.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oilers'72

Davo Ikinzom

Registered User
Nov 28, 2013
8,948
12,754
Edmonton
People keep citing injury history

Sounds like a coping mechanism.

uqur0pd1up5c1.jpeg
 

tiger_80

Registered User
Apr 11, 2007
10,341
3,609
This isn't revisionism. I had the two weakest links on the Oilers being Foegele and McLeod. I wish them the best of luck but they were not good fits for the Edmonton Oilers.
At least this regime wastes no time to weed out passengers. In the past, the likes of Jaypoo were getting too much of a rope.

Just watched a whole lot of Savoie highlights. Damn he is skilled and has a nice shot. Can't wait to follow his progress.
Small, 1 game in the NHL, signed for three years. Sounds like a boom-and-bust project. But hey, they cleared the cap space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TopShelfGloveSide

TheNumber4

Registered User
Nov 11, 2011
44,191
55,119
By all accounts, he is an incredibly skilled player. His production backs it up. His NHL comparable is Brayden Point.

I hope they give him a full year in Bakersfield to polish his game and then he can come in to fill Jeff Skinner’s spot when we can no longer afford him lol
If he turns out to be Point. Wow.
 

tiger_80

Registered User
Apr 11, 2007
10,341
3,609
How good? Best points per game season besides Bedard in the WHL in the past 23 years.


I too remember when a desperate Oilers fan base tried to convince themselves trades like Hall for Larsson, and many others were good trades when they got completely hosed. That's really all that is.
Hall for Larsson was actually a decent trade in the context of 2016. I'd take Larsson over Hall even today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oilers'72

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,933
16,130
Edmonton, Alberta
Hall for Larsson was actually a decent trade in the context of 2016. I'd take Larsson over Hall even today.
It turned out ok especially given Hall's injuries in recent years, but it was still an overpay for a position of need at the time. This trade is obviously a much better example of the type of trade that Oilers fans used to cope over.
 

JordanGalhanth

Registered User
Apr 21, 2012
4,491
5,773
Hall for Larsson was actually a decent trade in the context of 2016. I'd take Larsson over Hall even today.
Not for the return. Should've been at least a first rounder and maybe a prospect considering how highly touted Hall was at the time.

OT, but it's sad to see how far Hall has fallen due to injuries.
 

Messrules11

6 Cups, elbows up.
Nov 23, 2018
5,759
6,539
At least this regime wastes no time to weed out passengers. In the past, the likes of Jaypoo were getting too much of a rope.


Small, 1 game in the NHL, signed for three years. Sounds like a boom-and-bust project. But hey, they cleared the cap space.
Khaira comes to mind as well. His career also died when we finally got rid of him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oilers'72

La Bamba

Tier 2 Fan
Aug 23, 2009
9,812
6,785
Hall for Larsson was actually a decent trade in the context of 2016. I'd take Larsson over Hall even today.
They definitely should’ve got more value for Hall at the time but sometimes you need to lose a trade to improve the team. I think this was that case. Besides Hall’s random Hart season, he hasn’t really been that good.

The only trade that has truly annoyed me since being an Oil fan in 06 is the Griffin Reinhart trade
 

McFlyingV

Registered User
Feb 22, 2013
23,933
16,130
Edmonton, Alberta
At least this regime wastes no time to weed out passengers. In the past, the likes of Jaypoo were getting too much of a rope.


Small, 1 game in the NHL, signed for three years. Sounds like a boom-and-bust project. But hey, they cleared the cap space.
At this point there isn't much to suggest that there is much "bust" likelihood with Savoie. He just put up one of the best WHL seasons of the past 20+ years. The only reason people are even mentioning him as a bust is because of his size, and I think thats really behind-the-times thinking. Small skilled players are littered throughout the league as impact or quality complementary players. We just signed one in Arvidsson. With the right balance in your line up like the Oilers have these types of players don't carry that much risk.
 

CROTT

Registered User
Aug 25, 2007
1,501
3,102
Edmonton
Broberg and Holloway's QO's are 874.125k (1.74825M). They are currently 354.167K over the cap with 21 roster players. If you sent down Josh Brown and Perry (2.15M) you would be cap compliant with 47.583K cap space on a 21 man roster.
I highly doubt they'd send Perry down, he would be the most likely to get claimed. Option is Ryan at a little over $250K less so it screws over the savings to fit a 21 man roster.

Most likely it will be Ryan, J. Brown, and Stecher sent to Bako to fit a signed Holloway and Broberg. QO doesn't mean thats what they sign for as thats the minimum probably closer to 1 million (~$950K) a piece.
 

Jumptheshark

Rebooting myself
Oct 12, 2003
100,955
14,832
Somewhere on Uranus
unless the injury talk is correct.. we won this trade. One observation from another site is that some compared him to Gilbert Brule.

At the end of the day we traded a player with no future on the team for a guy who MIGHT be something in a few years.

Only time will tell
 

The Nuge

Some say…
Jan 26, 2011
28,014
9,298
British Columbia
This isn't revisionism. I had the two weakest links on the Oilers being Foegele and McLeod. I wish them the best of luck but they were not good fits for the Edmonton Oilers.

Ya, they weren’t healthy scratched in the playoffs for no reason

Yeah plan should be full year in the AHL with the potential for a call up later in the year if he's dominating the AHL. 5 points in 6 games at the start of last year in the AHL is a good sign.

Could be a "TDL" addition like Holloway was this year, and if not he seems like a logical Skinner replacement next year as you said.

That’s exactly the goal I’d imagine. He might get some games earlier if there are injuries

How good? Best points per game season besides Bedard in the WHL in the past 23 years.


I too remember when a desperate Oilers fan base tried to convince themselves trades like Hall for Larsson, and many others were good trades when they got completely hosed. That's really all that is.

Ya I remember going through it with the Reinhart trade. You justify it to yourself because you want to believe things are turning around.

Khaira comes to mind as well. His career also died when we finally got rid of him.

Not really. He’s played NHL games every year since. He just had major concussion issues
 
  • Like
Reactions: Messrules11

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad