Habs76
Registered User

1/9: D Denton Mateychuk, Moose Jaw Warriors, WHL
2/41: D Lane Hutson, USNTDP, USNTDP
2/53: LW Kirill Dolzhenkov, Krasnaya Armiya Moskva, MHL
3/73: D Liam Steele, Stanstead College, CAHS
Well there is not too many Rutgers around. Nobody going to pass on Slafkovsky for Cooley. Nobody knowledgable anyway. Slaf has Anderson size and speed with Pastrnak shot. Not going to see that again in 5 years. Cooley is small skilled center. The only advantage he has is a center. Didn't you fellows that lesson last time picking third? Drafting on position than skill. Taking Koktaniemi over more skilled forwards like Tkaczuk?How should anyone know you were talking about McGroarty ?
And anyway, @bopeep has his own views on the way he handles his choices, use yours for the team you own in this mock.
What's your team, by the way ?
In fact Slafkovsky look more like KK then Cooley. Cooley and KK are 2 completely different players and pedigree.Well there is not too many Rutgers around. Nobody going to pass on Slafkovsky for Cooley. Nobody knowledgable anyway. Slaf has Anderson size and speed with Pastrnak shot. Not going to see that again in 5 years. Cooley is small skilled center. The only advantage he has is a center. Didn't you fellows that lesson last time picking third? Drafting on position than skill. Taking Koktaniemi over more skilled forwards like Tkaczuk?
draft so far:
1/9: D Denton Mateychuk, Moose Jaw Warriors, WHL
2/41: D Lane Hutson, USNTDP, USNTDP
2/53: LW Kirill Dolzhenkov, Krasnaya Armiya Moskva, MHL
3/73: D Liam Steele, Stanstead College, CAHS
Nonsense, Cooley has Clayton Keller upside. He's skilled but not 40 goal scorer skill. A 55 point two way small centerIn fact Slafkovsky look more like KK then Cooley. Cooley and KK are 2 completely different players and pedigree.
It's a lot of really high upside picks - and not that this was by design, but I feel like it's a draft pretty in line with Detroit's image and their draft history tooThat's a fun draft you have going for yourself, I kinda like it.
Keller is a close to PPG player this season, if Cooley bring that type of offence with a great defensive game and a little bit more edge in his then Keller he would be a great player.Nonsense, Cooley has Clayton Keller upside. He's skilled but not 40 goal scorer skill. A 55 point two way small center
Taking Koktaniemi over more skilled forwards like Tkaczuk
Wow! That's really high for Steele. Generally, he's viewed as a 6th-7th rounder. One of my favorites for Montreal in 5th-7th rounds.select LHD Liam Steele from Stanstead College
“An enormous defenseman with incredibly raw physical tools, we feel the sky is the limit with Steele and that at this point in the draft, we can justify the risk”
PMing
Well there is not too many Rutgers around. Nobody going to pass on Slafkovsky for Cooley. Nobody knowledgable anyway. Slaf has Anderson size and speed with Pastrnak shot. Not going to see that again in 5 years. Cooley is small skilled center. The only advantage he has is a center. Didn't you fellows that lesson last time picking third? Drafting on position than skill. Taking Koktaniemi over more skilled forwards like Tkaczuk?
It's a lot of really high upside picks - and not that this was by design, but I feel like it's a draft pretty in line with Detroit's image and their draft history too
In all fairness, the rankings from some of those sources including Bobby Mac's (the most important one given it's actual NHL teams) were from before the Olympics which was Slaf's coming out party. RLR and HP have Slaf at #2 and Cooley at #'s 4 and 5 respectively.EP Cooley #5, Slaf #6
FCHockey Cooley #2, Slaf #4
Bob Mckenzie Cooley #2, Slaf #5
McKeen Cooley #4, Slaf #7
Button Cooley #2, Slaf #3
Recruit Scouting Cooley #2, Slaf #6
Dobber Cooley #5, Slaf #14
Draft Pro Cooley #3, Slaf #4
Smath Scouting Cooley #3, Slaf #7
Puck Authority Cooley #2, Slaf #6
Sportsnet Cooley #4, Slaf #2
The Aggregate ranking on EP has Cooley #2, Slaf #5.
I guess only Sportsnet is knowledgeable. You should go ask Mckenzie which NHL scouts he asked so you can get them fired for not being knowledgeable.
That's a nice pick! I can't see him going close to this late in the real entry draft.Winnipeg is thrilled to pick from the Kingston Frontenac Centre Paul Ludwinski. Next gm being pm'ed
In all fairness, the rankings from some of those sources including Bobby Mac's (the most important one given it's actual NHL teams) were from before the Olympics which was Slaf's coming out party. RLR and HP have Slaf at #2 and Cooley at #'s 4 and 5 respectively.
I like both players a lot. Slaf's upside with his skills/size combo has me very intrigued.
Very niceWith the 78th pick the Toronto Maple Leafs are proud to select: from the Kamloops Blazers RW Matthew Seminoff !
Player with skills but mostly a great motor and compete level.
@Stive Morgan have been PM
I just went back and re-read his original post you're referring to. Yeah...he's way off base with his "Nobody knowledgable anyway" garbage. There's good arguments for both Cooley and Slaf. Different players but both very high end prospects.The problem is not saying that Slaf is better than Cooley. I am still not sure who I would pick between them. I have no problem with people having one or the other at #2 (or even #1).
The problem is saying it is the only legitimate opinion and that people who like Cooley more do not know hockey which is what the poster I replied to did. We're here to have fun, not blast each other.
Considering I can't see who's posting this nonsense, I'm sure the opinion holds 0 weight.I just went back and re-read his original post you're referring to. Yeah...he's way off base with his "Nobody knowledgable anyway" garbage. There's good arguments for both Cooley and Slaf. Different players but both very high end prospects.