Doesn't make sense for either team, but the Ottawa responses are pretty funny. Kesler is being severely underrated.
It's probably because we're giving away a player that had basically the same point totals in the last 2 seasons as a 21 and 22 year old compared to a guy that was 30 and 31 years old.
We're also a budget team, so paying Kesler 3 times the salary that Zibanejad is making right now is just insane. Zibanejad is getting paid 2.65M this season, while Kesler is making 7.875M. Ottawa would be insanely stupid to do that while adding a Pageau who was leading scorer on the PK last season in the NHL, and managed to score 19 goals and 43 points.
I think Sens fans get that Kesler ultimately provides more value than Zibanejad on the ice right now, but the value also needs to consider the age difference, the salary difference and the fact that both these players are fairly close right now whether we like it or not.
Zibanejad just went PPG for the last 20 games of the season after Turris went down. He was our clear cut #1 centre for those 20 games and he answered extremely well. No reason for Ottawa to trade a cost controlled asset that keeps on getting better for a more complete, yet much older and expensive player.
Closer value would be Zibanejad straight up for Kesler, but with the salary difference and age difference, Ottawa wouldn't do it. Getting Kesler at that salary would mean getting rid of Hoffman or not being able to re-sign key pieces like Stone, Turris, Karlsson, Ceci, Hoffman in the next couple of years. I honestly think Anaheim would be crazy to not do a deal Zibby vs Kesler, being a budget team themselves.