NotCommitted
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2013
- 2,881
- 4,009
What do people see in Carlsson that puts him clearly ahead of someone like Lundell as a prospect? Very similar production in their draft years (SHL vs Liiga, SHL is arguably the better league these days but shouldn't be a big difference) - because of covid Lundell didn't have the opportunity to play WJC or WHC in his draft season, but the next year he did well (7gp 6+4=10 in WJC and 10gp 3+4=7 in mens tournament). Barkov for example was within sniffing distance of P/GP in Liiga during his draft season, while Carlsson & Lundell are/were more like 0.6P/GP.
Honest question and not meant as any kind of dig at Carlsson, like I've kept saying I haven't really watched any of these kids play much at all and Lundell is a great player who was an absolute steal at 12OA. Watching FLA in these playoffs, many nights the real difference in the games has been that 3rd line centered by Lundell and he also plays PK and if he played for the Jackets I think he'd be the #1 or #2 center depending on how they put together the lines.
Personally I think proleague players are pretty safe picks, so that's in Carlsson favor in this years draft. Again going back to Lundell's draft year, there were plenty of forward prospects that went before him because of their junior totals, but many of those guys have yet to make the NHL or have been really underwhelming compared to Lundell.
Honest question and not meant as any kind of dig at Carlsson, like I've kept saying I haven't really watched any of these kids play much at all and Lundell is a great player who was an absolute steal at 12OA. Watching FLA in these playoffs, many nights the real difference in the games has been that 3rd line centered by Lundell and he also plays PK and if he played for the Jackets I think he'd be the #1 or #2 center depending on how they put together the lines.
Personally I think proleague players are pretty safe picks, so that's in Carlsson favor in this years draft. Again going back to Lundell's draft year, there were plenty of forward prospects that went before him because of their junior totals, but many of those guys have yet to make the NHL or have been really underwhelming compared to Lundell.