Maybe I’m reading this all differently than you but my reading of it was Renya’s extremely poor performance and effort in training before the tournament actually began was a key reason he didn’t play much.
If so I 100% understand Berhalter’s decision. I mean I guess we could do the old Allen Iverson practice thing but while Renya absolutely could become a great player, he is far from that level now, IMO, and has no business disrespecting his teammates and coaches by half-assing it to such a degree in the immediate buildup to the tournament.
If you are looking to do something in the World Cup as the US, looking the other way while one of your more talented players mails it in during practice isn’t the way to do it, again IMO. There is a level of professionalism that has to be absolutely expected from everyone when you are a 3rd tier team in this kind of tournament.
So IMO this is 100% on Renya, based on what I have read so far.
From what I’m reading and hearing he was told he wasn’t starting the Wales game right off the bat. The team was essentially told the starting lineup in the opening days of camp. Reyna’s attitude was a result and it dipped even worse after he didn’t feature against Wales.
I think he could have handled it better for sure but I get it. He worked his ass off to get back to fitness after a year of injuries at Dortmund and he wanted to play. He deserved to play. He earned the right to play with his club and country performances. I’d be lying if I said I didn’t act similarly once or twice in my younger days and players I’ve coached have done the same. Ultra competitive athletes want to be on the field all the time and they want to win and if they’re not they don’t always handle it well. It’s on the player to correct himself and it’s also on the coach to have the emotional intelligence to work through it.
Look at the guys who defended Gregg and have been outspoken about bringing him back: Aaron Long, Walker Zimmerman, Deandre Yedlin, Jordan Morris, Kellen Acosta. Look at the guys Gregg has clashed with: Gio, John Brooks, Mark McKenzie, Matt Miazga, Pepi, Jordan Pefok, Zach Steffen. Gregg has a preference for plugs who are rah-rah guys who are just happy to be there and are fine with kissing the ring. He has a problem working with players who won’t buy what he’s selling hook, line, and sinker. It’s probably not a coincidence that guys who are in Europe and know what a real manager looks like don’t buy his act.
All of this is to say that Gregg shouldn’t be back. It’s time to move on.