But what were the options if we shut Meier down?
More games for Bowers? More Laberge? Willmon? More minutes for Tierney? Meier battling through was not a liability vs's the alternatives.
I can see the "medical staff sucks" is the narrative du jour, and will probably run all summer and into next year, but it already looks over inflated.
Are people seriously questioning if rest helps recover from injuries?
You can't force a player to get surgery but you can force them to sit their ass in the press box. Players don't decide who dresses, the coaches do. Either the staff were unwilling/unable to bench Timo until he got healthy, or they were specifically told to ply him through it by Fitzgerald and management. The more I hear about it, the more I think it's the later.
The issue with soft tissue injuries is that they don't always show up on MRIs. If you can see the damage, you still may not be able to understand the extent of the injury.
It seems to me that the relative severity a soft tissue injury is often identified by asking the patient when something hurts and how much. If the patient says it doesn't really hurt, or that the pain is manageable, what then?
Or, if an injury is such that it won't heal without significant rest and rehab or potentially surgery, but it also is something that could be played through - but the player will need to learn how to adjust to the injury...what then? Do you shut just shut the player down for a significant amount of time? Or do you take them at 50% today hoping they can learn to get to 80% in a couple of weeks?
People act like these decisions are simple. And they are when there's nothing on the line. But, when there's millions of dollars in salary, revenue on the line and you've got hypercompetitive players involved, it's seems way more complex.