This sounds good in a vacuum but it would be nearly impossible to bring up Muk, Nemec, and Luke into the NHL all at the same time.
It made sense to move on from Muk when we did. I think the Devils were hoping Bahl could be the second/third pairing LD with size this team needed. Also likely factored into Muk being traded.
If the team doesn’t think Bahl will cut it, Chychrun is a really interesting target, with Bahl as part of the package.
Agree. I kept my initial comment short to keep the focus on whether or not we could have still used Mukhamadullin.
I think you're right that the Devils would be better off finding an experienced 24 - 27 year old defender. My pick is Mario Ferraro. Yes - his metrics suck, but a) he shouldn't need to carry the same load here; b) he should be way cheaper to acquire; and c) he's signed for two more years at a reasonable cost. With Chychrun and Hanifin, cost to acquire and cost to sign will likely be a lot higher.
This is the point I think that
@Triumph was making that the Devils would have been looking for another Siegenthaler. We don't necessarily need offense from that spot, but we do need someone who can provide good defense and who is reasonably priced. That said, I still don't think this disqualifies Mukhamadullin if he were here. But, he's not, so whatever.