Hey Tonelli, with what you've seen of the Kings prospects, what do you agree/disagree with, if you don't mind me singling you out?
I'm just curious in terms of what I'm seeing and how far off I am from the professionals
Had a little time so I thought I would try and give you my thoughts.
I do want to start by saying that on our cup championship team we had the following rookies on our team.
Loktionov had played a total of 58 NHL games prior to the two games he played for us in the playoffs making him a rookie.
Jordan Nolan had played a total of 26 NHL games and was a rookie.
VV had 54 games and was a rookie.
D King had a total of 33 NHL games and was a rookie.
TLewis had played in 11 NHL games spanning two seasons prior to his rookie year which was during our cup run in 11/12.
The team we won the cup with had 4 rookie forwards and one rookie D. This isn't anything to do with what you have written but more just posting in this response that teams can and do carry multiple rookies with them at the same time and can win a cup too.
We will see Toffi next season and Frattin too giving us two rookies with some certainty. It wouldn't surprise me to see Vey Pearson AndyA and possibly Kozun spend some time with the big club this coming season up front and Deslauriers or possibly Forbort for a cup of tea on D too.
Just spouting off about the potential for a great team to not only be capable of carrying multiple rookies and still win a cup, not that I think we should or would have to do so again.
Since I am not able to be at camp this year I can only respond to what your observations are in commenting on how they either are or aren't in line with what I have seen from the kids based on my previous experiences. So far everything I have read from those who have posted have been interesting to pretty spot on observations of how these players have looked throughout their developmental arc.
We have so many good posters here. I enjoy reading almost everything.
(I will respond to each in bold below your observations)
Forwards:
(37) Nick Shore - His release wasn't as devastating as yesterday. Good speed with the puck. Cerebral type of approach when it came to getting open with a defender on him.
Right in line with everything I have ever seen in Nick. I once mistakenly said that his game awareness wasn't all that great and he proved me wrong over the two seasons since. So it isn't likely that you will see his or any of the kids best since you won't get to see them in actual game situations but Nick is a shifty/smart player who is an above average skater and likes to use speed and grit to make plays but if you follow him during the middle to later stages of a game it is his positional awareness that helps him stand out among his peers. He has a nice release to his shot but it isn't great. Good, but not great. I have a ton on NS but what you have written is in line with what I would expect from him. I see him as being just as ready as Vey who I think is going to be an exceptional player.
(38) Valentin Zykov - I know this is just practice, but I have yet to see a combination of skillsets or talents that show how he was so successful in the Q. He didn't really show a shot that was good for his age, He fell a couple times, and he just didn't have the speed or puck control that I might have unfairly expected out of him. Even without the Manchester players present to blow the curve, his talents, when isolated on the ice, just haven't blown me away. It might be a situation where he only really shines in game time and with competition, but right now I just don't see what the big draw is.
I have only seen tape on Zykov but believe he is a truly solid standout among his peers. That said he has also just finished his rookie season of NA hockey and will likely try to do too much in his first camp making him either a hero or a goat. So far it sounds like goat but I can only tell you that from what I have seen he is an elite level talent who will take 3 years of NA hockey (at least 1 year of AHL) before he can show his best to us at the NHL level. I think that your observations sound fair and I wonder if they have changed at all today.
(42) Scott Sabourin - He has a good wrist shot, but the more encouraging thing I see is his attempts to practice "right." In the puck control drills, there was a huge emphasis on skating and direction. Although his foot movements were deliberate and slow, they were done just as the coaching staff was telling him.
Needs to work on his skating. Needs to learn when to hit. Can shoot. Is a solid physical player who could end up being a useful utility guy.
(48) Maxim Kitsyn - His skating is getting there. It's a lot better than two years ago; his puck control is among the top of the group. Had some great shots.
Max has a great shot and is smart player who loves physical work. His strengths are his ability to keep the puck on his stick like it is glued there and his determination. He is smart and you won't see him out of position all to often if at all. Your right on the money.
(49) Joel Lowry - Unquestionably the fastest skater in the entire camp. Can really shoot too, given enough time.
I am a fan of his game but missed most of this season being out following the west/central. The two games I did see shows that he is still speedy and has good hands. He needs to find his game still so if you are watching him I would say that he is sort of stuck in between wanting to be just a solid all around player or a high end top 6er. He has the skills to make a go of either but he has a ways to go before he gets there. He is no doubt getting solid coaching at Cornell and entering his JR year it will be interesting to see where he is next summer.
(52) Tomas Hyka - He has effort on his side, but not the speed. I have concerns for a player his size, a transition to the professional level will be a very frustrating task for him.
Sounds right.
(55) Michael Mersch - Still heavy footed, still has a great shot. Hand-eye coordination was exceptional when it came to deflections.
This past season was his best in every area of play in my opinion. He can do it all and be a real presence when he wants to but his skating needs work. I saw him play several times and he is climbing the ladder from outside shot to could just make it. He will need to finish school and then spend a year in the AHL at least but if he keeps working hard I wouldn't be surprised to see him in our bottom 6 in 3 years.
(60) Jordan Weal - Got pushed around by equally sized forward Brian O'Neill. Needs to add strength. Gets pissed though. I like it.
Weal has tons of talent but does get pushed around a bit. Sounds like you are seeing what most everyone else does here.
I will get to the rest later but so far so good. Everyone who has written down their observations seem to be seeing allot of what I see during the year. Keep em coming!