Proposal: Detroit-Pittsburgh

[Voodoo Glow Skulls]

Beauvillier
Grzelcyk
Brunicke

For

Kane
James
Hanas

Click to read more...

 

[Bishop7979]

No... God no.

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Can’t decide who should even care about this trade. Sure from this Pittsburgh fan, just to see Kane with Sid would be cool.

 

[iago]

No... God no.

My feelings exactly from Detroits point of view.

 

[Empoleon8771]

Literally on what planet is a team in Pittsburgh's situation trading one of their top prospects in Brunicke for a rental Kane?

My feelings exactly from Detroits point of view.

This is downright highway robbery for the Wings. 2 prospects not even in their top-15 (according to Wheeler) and Kane for Brunicke alone is a criminal.

Brunicke nearly made the Penguins out of camp this year, he was their last cut going into the season.

 

[bellringer77]

I’d do this as a wings fan

 

[bellringer77]

My feelings exactly from Detroits point of view.

Shouldn’t be. Brunicke would be a big add for Detroits right side. He is better then anyone not named ASP in our defense pool, who hasn’t even played on North American ice

 

[Maurice of Orange]

Beauvillier
Grzelcyk
Brunicke

For

Kane
James
Hanas

Detroit has to return more then that just for losing a talent like James alone.

 

[Ulf5]

Detroit has to return more then that just for losing a talent like James alone.

Dylan James who isn't in anyone's list of top 15 Red Wings' prospects? Nah, we're good.

 

[Peat]

Not that I expect to be convinced but what exactly is the OP's rationale for this one?

 

[Hobnobs]

Dylan James who isn't in anyone's list of top 15 Red Wings' prospects? Nah, we're good.

I'm pretty sure it was sarcasm

 

[FriendlyGhost92]

Literally on what planet is a team in Pittsburgh's situation trading one of their top prospects in Brunicke for a rental Kane?



This is downright highway robbery for the Wings. 2 prospects not even in their top-15 (according to Wheeler) and Kane for Brunicke alone is a criminal.

Brunicke nearly made the Penguins out of camp this year, he was their last cut going into the season.

A mid 2nd defensemen making the NHL 4 months after the draft sounds more like shit player development decisions than a testament to his ability...

 

[Empoleon8771]

A mid 2nd defensemen making the NHL 4 months after the draft sounds more like shit player development decisions than a testament to his ability...

Sounds like someone who didn't watch Brunicke in training camp whatsoever.

 

[Duffy13]

woof, ok, throw this out, what else you got?

 

[FriendlyGhost92]

Sounds like someone who didn't watch Brunicke in training camp whatsoever.

Sounds like somebody watching a bad prospect pool who thinks a guy being one of their better prospects makes him a good overall prospect.

Would love to see an all-time list of all the 18 year old non Top 10 D-Men who stepped in the NHL and didn't get annihilated.

 

[Empoleon8771]

Sounds like somebody watching a bad prospect pool who thinks a guy being one of their better prospects makes him a good overall prospect.

Would love to see an all-time list of all the 18 year old non Top 10 D-Men who stepped in the NHL and didn't get annihilated.

I don't even know what you're blabbing on about at this point. Bruncike was excellent for the Penguins in camp and it has made pretty much every Penguins fan really excited about him.

Zero Penguins fans want to trade Brunicke for a rental Patrick Kane and 2 no-name prospects.

 

[FriendlyGhost92]

I don't even know what you're blabbing on about at this point. Bruncike was excellent for the Penguins in camp and it has made pretty much every Penguins fan really excited about him.

Zero Penguins fans want to trade Brunicke for a rental Patrick Kane and 2 no-name prospects.

Again, you're welcome to list the dozens of 18 year old Non Top 10 defensemen who have stepped into the NHL and impressed.

 

[Hobnobs]

Again, you're welcome to list the dozens of 18 year old Non Top 10 defensemen who have stepped into the NHL and impressed.

Not sure what this has to do with Brunicke being a very good prospect?

The rest of your posts just screams, "I was asleep during pre-season and I don't follow junior hockey"

I don't even know what you're blabbing on about at this point. Bruncike was excellent for the Penguins in camp and it has made pretty much every Penguins fan really excited about him.

Zero Penguins fans want to trade Brunicke for a rental Patrick Kane and 2 no-name prospects.

Hanas I wouldnt say is a no-name prospect just like Brunicke isn't. However Brunicke definitely is the better prospect in this trade.